Really, this should have been started last week, when the earliest-starting series were first hitting episode 7s, but sometimes real life intrudes. Anyway, I have plenty of time this week and next for some extra writing, so let’s take a look at how a bevy of series this season that I’m not actively episode-reviewing are doing.
In all, I have somehow wound up staying mostly current with 23 series this season. A handful of others that I watched more than one episode of have fallen by the wayside; I likely won’t continue with Mashle: Magic and Muscle (mostly because I have just lost interest with its oddball gimmick) or My Instant Death Ability is Overpowered (because it’s just bad and seems to be poorly-adapted), but I am not ruling out watching more of The Weakest Tamer Began a Journey to Pick Up Trash or The Strongest Tank’s Labyrinth Raid at some point, as both had potentially endearing qualities but simply lost out to volume overload. Because trying to cover them all at once would be burdensome, I am dividing them into two groups. This group are titles that are not getting episode reviews on Anime News Network, and the second group (which will constitute next week’s installment) will deal with my take on titles that are getting coverage.
Banished from The Hero’s Party s2
Rating So Far: B
The first season was an unexpectedly solid performer which tossed out some intriguing ideas about how the Blessing bestowed on everyone (and even monsters) could influence the individual, especially how it can be difficult to ignore the Blessing in some cases. This season continues to explore that, both by looking at how Ruti’s new Blessing checks her Hero Blessing, thus allowing her to choose her own path, and how the new Hero fanatically embraces Blessings and preaches a worrying level of determinism about them. The notion that someone may be going around artificially giving monsters extra Blessings also comes up. The series still has plenty of low-key charm and sexiness, and seeing Ruti acting more and more like a regular human being is welcome, but it’s building a good balance between plot and fantasy world slice-of-life. Animation limitations prevent it from being a top-tier performer (the most recent episode in particular had significant quality control issues), but it’s still among the better series this season.
Doctor Elise: The Royal Lady with the Lamp
Rating So Far: B-
I’d really like to rate this one higher, as its combination of double-isekai and time travel gimmicks provides for some interestingly different possibilities. Also, rather than having an OP ability, Elise simply has the medical knowledge of a trained 21st century physician, knowledge that’s a century and a half more advanced than what exists in the setting where she’s a potential future Empress. (But it might as well be an OP ability, since she can perform medical procedures that flabbergast the current medical community.). There’s also something very satisfying about seeing her struggle to avoid her fate by pursuing the new calling she discovered in her second life in modern Japan, rather than by just being a better future Empress. However, the series isn’t even trying to avoid over-dramatizing its medical procedures and is taking a very by-the-numbers approach to having Elise unwittingly win over the prince/future husband that she never really connected with the first time around. As a result, certain aspects of the series feel redundant in a season that also has the conceptually-similar 7th Time Loop. Mediocre technical merits also hamper the series some, but not to the point of denying the appeal of Elise as a strong female protagonist.
Fluffy Paradise
Rating So Far: C+
If I had to describe this series in one word, it would be “saccharine.” But what else would you expect from a series where the protagonist is an adult woman on the inside mostly embracing her little-girl-on-the-outside to spend her days hanging out with floofy animals and monsters – and if some of them happen to be Holy Beasts, dragons, or even goblins, so what? This is a much more cutesy, relaxing series than most other isekai, and it has to be accepted at that level in order to be tolerable. For those wanting more from a series, there are hints of bigger machinations and broader realities in the setting (and the underlying current of God seeking an evaluation of how humans treat non-humans still lingers in the background) and the series isn’t entirely ignoring how potentially strategic Nema’s capabilities are; it would definitely be more involving if it stressed the latter aspect more, though. Still, the series functions well enough as the kind of thing you might watch while eating breakfast to get your day started off right.
Hokkaido Girls are Super-Adorable!
Rating So Far: C+
Honestly, there’s not a lot to this one; it’s just a basic, slice-of-life harem series. The only distinguishing features so far are that it’s set in winter in Hokkaido and all of the girls are gyaru to some degree. The most recent episodes have introduced the third, slightly older girl, so we now have a busty blonde genki girl, a more subdued brunette who’s secretly a gamer, and the senpai with short, pale hair and possibly mixed blood. All are, of course, beautiful and have befriended protagonist Tsubasa. Each may also already have feelings for him to some degree, though there’s no full-blown romance yet. The series annoys some by having Tsubasa spend too much of his time being utterly flustered (but what boy his age wouldn’t be, with girls like these three around?), but the most recent episodes have shown that he has some tensions at home that are already causing conflict. The trio of ladies also have no shortage of sex appeal, though the series has largely avoided full-blown fan service so far. Worthwhile if you appreciate the genre, but unlikely to win over outsiders.
Ishura
Rating So Far: B+
If any series in this group is strongly crying out to be reviewed episode-by-episode, it’s this one. (I almost considered doing it myself.) The series took a big risk with an approach that could easily discourage many viewers: its first five episodes are a collection of mostly-disparate stories which each focus on one or two characters who are each going to play roles in a grand power struggle between an empire and an offshoot city-state. Each of these episodes gradually moves the overall timeline forward as characters start to converge, with paths finally crossing – and featured characters coming into open conflict with each other – starting with episode 6. (And episode 7 even provides the first death of a featured character.) The technical merits here are by far the strongest of any title in this group, the graphic content can occasionally be intense, and the plotting is as dense and intricate as any series airing this season. The wealth of angles it takes on the story can be both a blessing and a hindrance (in the sense that significant effort is required to keep track of all the moving pieces), but it certainly isn’t boring. This could wind up being the most under-appreciated title of the season.
Synduality: Noirs2
Rating So Far: B
The first season proved to be a competent mecha-like series with hints of a bigger picture, and the second half definitely explores that bigger picture further. We now have a more concrete idea about what Histoire is, what other forces are moving in this setting, and who’s really affiliated with what group, including one significant surprise reveal. Most importantly, these episodes spend considerable time exploring who and what Mystere is, how she’s related to Noir, and how both play crucial roles in this setting. All the familiar faces are also back from last season, and both of the last two episodes have ended with startling, game-changing developments. I still have some mixed feelings about the mecha action elements, but this series looks better than most and is certainly keeping things interesting.
Tales of Wedding Rings
Rating So Far: C
Some male protagonists wind up with harems by happenstance. In the case of protagonist Satou, though, the harem is by design, since he’s supposed to form a marriage-like bond with five Ring Princesses in order to access assorted elemental and light powers as the Ring King to fight off the encroaching baddies. By the time of this writing he’s added an elf, a beastwoman, and now a dragonoid to the human girl (and longtime childhood friend) that he started with, and one more is still to come. The problem is that Satou comes across as too pathetic to warrant all of these feminine beauties or be a threat to be feared; granted, this isn’t unusual for the genre, but in a fantasy setting where he has to do direct battle, it’s more damning. Let’s not even get started about how basic the plot is, how limp the writing is, or how weak the action animation and choreography are. The only things keeping the series afloat are that the female character designs are sufficiently sexy and the fan service does include some nudity. (It’s decidedly less prevalent than in Gushing Over Magical Girls but still present.)
The Foolish Angel Dances with the Devil
Rating: B-
I’m a little behind on this one, so this evaluation only covers through episode 6 (of 7). So far it’s combined traits of a supernatural romcom and an initially-antagonistic romcom, with the main variation being that the male and female leads are both supernatural entities, rather than one of them being an ordinary human dragged into a bigger world. We’re also seeing the story about equally from the perspectives of both Lily and Masatora, which is definitely more unusual but very welcome. The story takes a more serious turn in episode 6, but to that point it’s been a sometimes-funny, mostly-enjoyable exercise in them being catty towards each other while trying to deny that they are attracted to each other, all while occasionally sprinkling in bits of supernatural action. (It has some mild fan service elements, too, but this is, on the whole, a tame series.) The technical merits are actually decent, so the grade is more a reflection of how I’ve had trouble getting enthusiastic about this one despite continuing to follow it.
The Undead Unwanted Adventurer
Rating So Far: B-
This is another series that I find interesting enough that I want to rate it higher, but its workmanlike approach and CG skeletons just don’t inspire a lot of excitement. Still, it works to a degree with an interesting twist on the reincarnation concept: an adventurer who dies in a dungeon is animated as an undead, but with his mental faculties completely intact. As the story progresses, he’s able to evolve into higher undead forms by leveling up, to the point that he can somewhat pass for human as long as he keeps his face and skin hidden, and now he’s easily passed the plateau that he was stuck at for years as a human adventurer. There are vague hints of a bigger plot and a couple of mildly tantalizing mysteries afloat, but the series is also increasingly struggling with staying on-model on the artistic front. Not one of the season’s most thrilling fantasy series, but still worth a look.
Tsukimichi -Moonlit Fantasy s2
Rating So Far: B-
This first season of Tsukimichi was the pleasantly fun surprise of the Summer 2021 season. While its second season still has some crazy antics, it has shifted to a more story and setting-developed focus, including episodes spent focusing on the two isekai’d students from Makoto’s world that do have the Goddess’s stamp of approval and how Makoto’s actions have indirectly affected them. That does allow for some interesting developments, such as the first instance I can recall of a summoned high school student literally being seduced into his Hero role, and some new intrigues do come up as Makoto goes to a magic school and winds up being an instructor. However, that has come at the expense of some of the craziness. It’s still an entertaining series, just not as sharp as it was before.
That’s it for now. Come back next week for part 2!
This episode represents the biggest dramatic peak in this part of the story. It is the culmination of everything that has happened so far this season and some details going back to last season, too, all bound together into one grand scheme, one greater even than the schemers who are active parts of the story. I knew this was coming from the source material, and anticipated that it would be one of the season’s highlights, but the adaptation effort here exceeds even those expectations. This is, easily, the best episode of any series that I have seen so far in the Winter ’24 season.
There are so many little details to parse here, but let’s start with the grand scenario at hand. Since the early stages of the series, there’s been a sense that someone is plotting something big in a very subtle fashion, and that sense has only increased since Maomao moved to working in the outer court. Given that the ultimate target seems to have been Jinshi (i.e., the Emperor’s younger brother), the plan had to operate by making all the steps look as coincidental as possible. Or perhaps, as Maomao postulated herself, a truly linear plot never existed, and instead, a net of incidents was thrown out that could conglomerate into something big in multiple different ways, depending on what worked and what didn’t. That seems to be the more likely scenario. The removal of an official a year ago set one possible direction for the plan in motion, and steps were then taken to reinforce that path as it became clear that a scheme to use a less sturdy part for the suspended banner rod in the ceremonial hall could be used. The only chance that anyone would link some food poisoning cases to a fire started by a careless smoker to a mystery about a metalworking formula would be if the same person were deeply involved in all of those incidents. Even so, even Maomao only ferreted out the scheme with the help of a coincidental encounter with someone who had formerly studied safety concerns in that very hall. In other words, the plan should have worked, and it took a truly extraordinary effort by one individual to thwart it.
The mystery effort provides a strong thrill factor, as does Maomao’s dramatic efforts to get into the ceremonial hall – something she only accomplishes with help from the least desirable figure imaginable to her. But it’s also interesting how Lakan fits into this. If he wasn’t present already in some official capacity then he may simply have seen Maomao running (she was definitely shown as being conspicuous in that act) and decided to follow here. While it might be logical to assume that he’s behind this, that doesn’t seem to be the case. Given that he examined some of the same cases that Maomao did, he must have had his own suspicions about an overarching plot, and since he had set Maomao on at least one of the key incidents, he reasonably could have suspected that Maomao had figured something out. Hence him stepping up was probably as much about him being curious to see what played out as it was about helping his daughter and being displeased with the one guard Maomao goaded. (That was quite the dark expression from a character otherwise seen always smiling.) And his expression at the end – as Jinshi was walking out with the unconscious Maomao – was quite telling. He was shocked, clearly the most thrown-off his game that we’ve yet seen him, so he wasn’t at all expecting either Maomao’s state or Jinshi to be carrying her or both.
In fact, the expression work in the episode is at least as much of a highlight as anything else here. It wasn’t just Lakan; Maomao also had her share of great expressions, too. The real champion on that, though, is Jinshi. The stunned expression he had at first after she saved him, the deeply concerned expression as she was passing out, and the severe, determined expression he wore as he carried Maomao out collectively makes for a great expressive range. Kudos also go to Aoi Yuki and Takeo Otsuka for some fantastic voice work as Maomao and Jinshi; they’ve been great all throughout the series so far, but haven’t shined more brightly than they do here. Strong scene-staging, good supporting animation, and on-point music also contribute.
The fallout from this will be big, and we still have yet to see how deeply Suirei is actually involved in all of this. (I’ll also be interested to see if next episode goes into more detail about how the metal buckles failed; the artistry gave a hint on that, and it does have something to do with things shown in the metalworker’s will incident, but narratively speaking, the story could get by without it.) However, this is a grand moment on the level of the “this is poison” incident, and the episode achieved here is one that I expect to rewatch many times to appreciate its excellence.
I was going to skip reviewing this one separately and just combine it with episode 19, rather than post a review this late. However, episode 18 turned out to be loaded, the culmination of many hints and mysteries presented to date, and the previews suggest that next episode will be even more loaded. (Okay, I’m not going to be coy here. I know what has to be coming next, and as big as this episode’s revelations are, next episode should be the most pivotal one of this season’s half of the series.) So let’s take a somewhat delayed look at what transpired.
Last episode ended – and this episode starts – with Maomao answering a stunned Jinshi’s question about what it means to “devalue” a high-ranking courtesan. Maomao commenting about how she managed to avoid showing emotion as she walks away suggests that this is a very personal matter for her, and much of the rest of the episode lays out why. Though never said bluntly or directly, the inescapable conclusion is that the woman laying in the annex, wasting away from an advanced case of syphilis, is the courtesan that Lakan was talking about to Jinshi in previous episodes, as well as Maomao’s biological mother. In other words, that means that Lakan is her father, and she is very probably the result of Lakan’s attempt to “devalue” said courtesan.
What the revelations here do not make clear is how much consent was involving in this event. Did Lakan taken Maomao’s mother forcibly, or was she fully complicit in the devaluation? The exact way Lakan worded things back in episode 16 suggests the latter; he’s a canny man who words things carefully, so I can’t imagine that he actually did force her after lamenting that he was tempted to do it but implied that he didn’t. If that is the case, though, then something else went horribly wrong, to the degree that Maomao’s mother may have tried to kill her when Maomao was just a toddler. Maomao’s narrative strongly implies that her mother was left with no choice but to start sleeping with customers regularly after having her, and somewhere in that process she contracted syphilis. Overwhelmed by how her life was collapsing, she took her frustrations out on a young Maomao. Though the episode doesn’t specify this, I’m guessing that Luomon – who arrived on the scene after the devaluation incident but before Maomao’s mother went full-blown into her affliction – probably adopted her in the wake of that incident.
All of this explains and links together a lot about Maomao’s circumstances: how she came to be an apothecary’s daughter, why she was practically raised in a brothel, how she came to be so beloved by Verdigris House’s stars, and why Lakan is so keenly interested in her. It explains why Maomao so glumly visited the annex in an earlier episode and why the disease-addled woman might not want to see Maomao. Assuming Maomao knows Lakan is her father (and based on her reaction to Jinshi when he mentioned that Lakan wants to meet her, I think it’s safe to say that she does), it also explains, to a degree, why she’s been so particular about asserting that she’s a commoner; it’s not just a way to keep Jinshi at a distance, but also a way to distance herself from the noble-born Lakan. This also explains why Maomao claimed in an earlier episode that she doesn’t have a mother. Who wouldn’t be emotionally detached from their parents under circumstances like these? I also do like the implication that Maomao is who she is because of her pedigree; she gets her hair color, respectable looks, and disposition from her mother, her eccentric way of approaching things from her father, and her intelligence from both.
The one big question not answered by this episode is why Maomao’s mother is still at Verdigris House rather than cast out on the street, as would seem to be the normal fate of a courtesan who can’t work anymore. Obviously she’s confined because of her advanced condition, but why keep her? That Meimei refers to her as “big Sis” suggests that she was one of Verdigris’s top courtesans in her time, but there has to be more to it. Does the old matron feel partly responsible, perhaps?
Artistically, the episode is definitely pulling some punches here compared to the manga version. The artistry conspicuously hides her nose behind thick strands of hair in every shot, because – as the manga version of those scenes shows – it has collapsed in a condition known as “saddle nose,” which is a known possible effect of tertiary-stage syphilis. Also artistically striking was one sequence around the 6:40 mark, which showed the mother with her fingernails, eye make-up, and sores highlighted in red before showing a tree outside also blooming red.
Maomao’s parentage is hardly the only thing going on this episode, however. Her conversations with Meimei and Pairin are also telling. The latter is apparently getting offers (but why would she leave when she can get all the sex she wants here?), and Meimei seems to be waiting for something herself. Based on her comments to Maomao while walking to the bath house, is she, perhaps, waiting for someone special to make her an offer, somewhat like the courtesan who left the Rear Palace back in episode 3? Jinshi is also shaken further both by guessing that Lakan is Maomao’s biological father and having to deal with Lakan seeming to know his real identity.
The latter part of the episode is also laying further groundwork for other plot lines, including one which seems to be centered around Suirei, the tall woman Maomao first met back in episode 14. Her cryptic comments here further suggest that she’s up to something – and based on the ominous music at the end of the episode, quite possibly something dastardly – and perhaps challenging Maomao to figure out what that is. The detail about the upcoming vegetarian meal isn’t an idle one, either; the importance of that will come up more immediately, though.
While this episode isn’t totally devoid of humor (or, for that matter, fan service), this is one of the more purely and heavily dramatic portions of the series likely to be adapted this season. This strong episode should be followed by another strong one if the adaptation teams sticks to form.
NOTE: The review for next week’s episode may also be later than normal due to a convention. After that, I don’t expect other delays through the end of the season.
There have been other strong episodes in this series, but this one is a microcosm of what makes this series stand apart from most other series out there. Its brilliance is in the balance it achieves in its execution; while mostly a fun, light-hearted episode about Maomao helping Jinshi to pass as a commoner for some secret meeting, it still excels in its analytical and world-building aspects and is still well-capable of turning darkly serious when need be. Kudos to the production staff for delivering on this flawlessly even as it is stretching out the source material a bit.
While much of the episode is presented in fanciful fashion, the premise is still firmly ground in reality: Jinshi just stands out too much in appearance to have any hope of going out into the capital city without attracting attention, and hooded cloaks either don’t exist in this setting or would still be much too conspicuous. Asking Maomao to make him up as a commoner is entirely logical, too; who better could he ask for something like that than a commoner who already regularly downgrades her own appearance and was raised in an environment where make-up was a matter of course? Maomao being Maomao, she gets to have a bit of fun with it, and Gaoshun and Suiren are more partners in crime than objecting. (You have to think both of them have had their own issues with Jinshi over time.) And Gaoshun being Gaoshun, he’s not about to let Maomao slip away without getting caught up in this, too. He understands that dressing Maomao up to escort the dressed-down Jinshi (or, rather, he’s technically escorting her in the guise of a servant) is practical, fits in well with Jinshi’s predilections, and is perhaps a bit of payback, too. Really, the whole scenario is both logically tight and delightfully slick.
The episode doesn’t miss any little details, too. Jinshi doesn’t understand at first how to properly walk as a servant or that his training in things like posture and etiquette are actually detrimental when trying to pass as a commoner, but he certainly seems to be enjoying his play-acting and isn’t about to let Maomao get away with acting out of character for the way she’s dressed, either; indeed, if the episode has a theme, it’s “act in a manner befitting your style of dress.” Basen, who’s been called in to surreptitiously serve as a bodyguard, also gets in on the action, too; in fact, the scenes where he’s first shown drooling over the chicken skewers and then later shown chowing down on multiple of them are some of the episode’s funniest moments, and that’s saying something.
Not everything is fun and games, however. Though Luomen has come up in Maomao’s thoughts plenty of times, this is the first time she’s actually talked about him in front of Jinshi. Frankly, a doctor/apothecary skilled enough to have been allowed to study Western medicine and who’s a eunuch aren’t details which Maomao attaches much significance to, but there’s no way Jinshi wouldn’t pick up on their significance; the number of people who could meet that description would have to be very, very small indeed, and he can probably narrow it down to one if one adds in that he’s servicing the brothels rather than having a high court position, as that would naturally imply someone who once had high standing but was dismissed.
But the point where the episode truly turns is when Jinshi finally gets around to doing what Lakan suggested to him last episode: asking a denizen of the brothels what “devaluing a courtesan” entails. Lakan no doubt fully intended that Jinshi was going to ask Maomao this, and this scene only heightens the sense of devious purpose behind that action. The way that the episode frames Jinshi’s question is beautifully chilling, from Maomao’s icy stare to the way the camera shifts out to a side view as he both asks the question and responds to Maomao’s explanation to the visuals used during her explanation to the more somber and heavy shift of the musical score. Being able to deliver a scene like this with such potentially devastating meaning despite the episode’s earlier high spirits is a feat that no other recent series outside of Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End could probably pull off.
There are plenty of other little details here, too, such as the unusually strong devotion to background animation in the scenes where Maomao is traveling around town with Jinshi, the care with which Jinshi chose his false name, and the (I think anime original) scene where Suiren is reminiscing about Jinshi with Gaoshun. The only very slight negative is a minor feel that the episode is stretching a little; I had expected it to get a big farther than this. Still, this is some great content, and more should be coming next episode.
NOTE: Due to a gaming convention I will be attending later this week, episode 18’s review will either be a day or two later than normal or else skipped entirely. In the latter case, I will cover it together with episode 19 the following week.
Another episode, another mystery for Maomao, but this time it’s a longer one – taking up nearly the whole episode – and doesn’t involve the cause of harm or death, but rather the aftermath of it. In other words, the mystery is a puzzling will.
One slight beef I’ve always had with mysteries like this is why the writer of the will bothered with such a roundabout way to make a point after his death. If the man was particularly clever and/or a trickster type, that would make more sense, but no, this man was an ordinary (if exceptionally talented) metalworker. Given the way things turn out in the end, the deceased’s goal was probably to maneuver his sons into working together to continue the family business, with each taking on his own specialty, and do it in a way where they wouldn’t feel like they were being dictated to from beyond the grave. And he may well have intended that the family business should end if the sons couldn’t work together to solve the mystery. Even so, he went through an awful lot of trouble to set this up, to the point that I have to wonder how he was able to do it without his sons wondering what he was up to.
But that’s ultimately a minor detail. The cleverness of the whole set-up is a physical level beyond anything we’ve seen previously, but the clues are all there. Moreover, the episode doesn’t hide the clues until Maomao puts them together; an astute viewer will notice the square that isn’t sun-bleached on the table before Maomao does, as well as the conspicuous way the sunlight shines in.
While the mystery is the focus of the episode, though, Jinshi’s interactions with Lakan are nearly as interesting and revealing. I don’t doubt at all that an official could go far in a bureaucracy just by being an excellent judge of talent and recruiting the right people to work under him, but Lakan also clearly has a wickedly sharp intellect. This whole affair was a talent investigation, both for the metalworker and for Maomao, and there’s no question that he’s meaning Jinshi to ask Maomao about what could lower a courtesan’s value. A guy like him wouldn’t do that without ulterior motive.
Anothe random thought: Could the similarity in appearance that Maomao notices between Basen and Gaoshun be meant to indicate that Basen is Gaoshun’s son? Even if Gaoshun is a eunuch now, that doesn’t mean he was always one.
In general, this was another good-looking and solidly-executed episode all around. I am very much looking forward to seeing how the content covered by the next episode is adapted, as certain aspects of it are on the edgier side. Look forward to it!
If you’re an anime-only viewer, this episode is one you might want to bookmark to come back and watch again later on, as it drops a mountain of hints about certain bigger pictures in the series. And those hints are coming on two different fronts that may or may not be related.
In the first half of the series, Maomao dealt with several mysteries that still seem entirely unrelated, though at least one of them – the matter of the chemically-treated boards – still lingers. This half has started off with a succession of them, too, but it’s harder to shake the impression that, this time around, there may be some connection. Last episode, the matter was the warehouse fire and the mysterious, out-of-place pipe which probably triggered it. This episode, the initial mystery is a rather clever poisoning scheme, one involving a type of seaweed that’s only safe to eat if prepared a certain way. Only someone like Maomao, who is deeply steeped in poison knowledge, could probably figure out that deliberate rather than accidental shenanigans were going on here, which only makes someone telling the culprit about it in a bar all the more suspicious. Could someone have been deliberately targeting this particular merchant? If so, the circumstances being similar to the incident 10 years ago certainly suggest a connection, perhaps even the same method having been used twice. I found it a little too convenient that the writing just let that point slide away. And it looks like the next case to fall in Maomao’s lap will be about the legacy of an Imperial metalworker. If someone’s plotting someone here, they’re burying their moves deep.
The other front involves Lakan, who has briefly popped up in each of the last two episodes and is now taking center stage in the back third of this one. Maomao’s reactions to Jinshi talking about it, and the way the camera focuses on her in that scene, certainly suggests that she knows Lakan (or at least knows of him) but would rather not. Just as interesting is the story he spins to Jinshi about the courtesan at Verdigris house that he knew, one who was smart enough to match even an imperial strategist at games and had an attitude much like one might imagine Maomao having if she ever became a courtesan. Jinshi thinks of Maomao in a joking fashion at the point, but how much of a joke is it, really? After all, the one brief shot of the courtesan in question showed that she has the same hair color as Maomao, and this would hardly be the first time that matching hair color has been used in the series to imply mother/child connections. If Maomao is, indeed, this courtesan’s daughter, then that explains a lot of comments, relations, attitudes, and actions which have transpired so far, including why Lakan is interested in Jinshi’s new servant.
If Maomao is aware of Lakan’s connection to the courtesan who may well be her mother, then that also explains her negative reaction and desire to avoid the subject. That’s especially pertinent in light of Lakan’s cryptic comment about lowering the courtesan’s value. That sounds unsavory at the very least, and downright ugly at worst.
Naturally, this series can’t go a full episode being completely serious. Jinshi accidentally walking into Maomao’s giddy “welcome home” gets a reaction from him which may be the single funniest moment to date in the series. (At the very least, it’s on the level of his reaction to Maomao describing how she rewarded Lihaku for escorting her to Verdigris.)
In any case, one of the best features of this series has always been that its cast is stocked with highly-intelligent and/or perceptive people (Lihaku aside). Plenty of that is one display throughout this episode, and Lakan represents an intimidating presence on that front. That well help the series stay lively.
Episode 14 contains the sequence that I was probably most looking forward to seeing animated from this part of the story: Maomao’s lessons to the four high-ranking consorts on how to please the Emperor, a task warranted by the arrival of the new (and presumed to be sexually inexperienced) Pure Consort. That she ended up in this role at all is amusing in itself, but she does have access to the expertise of Verdigris House, after all, and it’s not surprising that a long-lived, prestigious establishment like that would have formal training materials. Nor is it surprising that she would pull recommendations from both Lihua and Gyokuyou because of her deeds while in the Real Palace (although you still have to think that Gyokuyou once again did that for her own personal amusement). The reactions of the three established consorts all suit their established characters, while the reaction of the new consort is interesting.
The new Pure Consort is Loulan, who looks like she’s probably between Lishu and Gyokuyou in age. In an anime-original scene, the episode opens with her entering the Rear Palace with her entourage, in a scene where the coloring of her robes, skin, jewelry, and umbrella stand out starkly against the muted coloring of everything else. Everything about the tone of that scene and her later intense stares at the camera suggests that she is a very proper and dignified young woman, but also less than thrilled to be here, and the way she acts in the training sessions suggests that she has little interest in trying to please the Emperor even though he will doubtless be visiting at some point. Certainly feels like she may have stronger ulterior motives than the other high-ranking consorts, but don’t expect that point to be revisited anytime soon.
That’s partly because there more immediate incidents to be dealt with. Last episode ended with a scene of someone giving someone else an ornate smoking pipe, and now that same pipe has turned up in a warehouse that exploded and caught fire. Naturally, Maomao can’t help but get involved when she comes across Lihaku investigating it the next day. That fine powder – whether flour, sawdust, or something similar – in the air create very flammable conditions is fairly common knowledge these days, but in this kind of setting, anyone who’s never directly dealt with materials like that probably wouldn’t suspect that as the culprit. Though Maomao is able to prove that someone taking a smoke likely ignited the incident, the question lingers about why such a nice-looking pipe would have been in the possession of a common worker. Given last episode’s ending scene, this smacks of an incident that was deliberately engineered, but to what end? And why did Mr. Monocle (aka Lakan) leave the pipe behind at the scene when he clearly had a good guess about what happened from the way he was investigating? A couple of different threads are overlapping here, portending wider, more tangled mysteries to come.
But first is going to be the matter with the fellow that’s drinking at the end of the episode. We’ll come back to him next episode.
After a week off, the second half of the series begins, shifting the adaptation into the territory of the second light novel and the 5th manga volume. This also marks a significant change in the setting: instead of being in the Rear/Inner Palace, Maomao is now working in the Outer Palace, directly under Jinshi. (Fear not about the Rear Palace being left behind, however; as the Next Episode preview hints, she’ll be back there for a visit shortly.) While that makes this effectively a set-up episode for the second half of the series, there’s still a lot going on here, and especially a lot of little hints about future directions.
One of those details is the little drinking session Jinshi has with the Emperor. It’s placed significantly earlier here than it was in the manga version, but I think the scene fits better at the beginning, as a precursor to everything, as it gives a better sense of where Jinshi is coming from and draws an interesting comparison/contrast between him and Maomao. That scene, and other snippets throughout the series to date, suggest that Jinshi feels like he’s only being appreciated for his looks when he’d rather be appreciated for his work, but he doesn’t have the option to disguise his natural beauty. Maomao does – except when others get in their heads to use her as a living dress-up doll, of course – and so she is getting appreciated for her efforts first and (when she reveals it) her looks second. Jinshi is clearly taken by her appearance when she dolls up, but that’s not what first drew him to her. That she’s able to do what he cannot could be a big part of his interest.
Of course, nothing that happens with Jinshi is without complications. He can’t keep servant help beyond the old woman who’s been seen wiping him down before because everyone falls for him, which makes Maomao the ideal attendant, even though Jinshi has higher aims for her. Naturally other court lady admirers are going to get jealous and catty, and naturally the prodigious skill and practical knowledge that Maomao has shown so far causes him to overestimate her ability to pass the test to become a court lady (essentially a court secretary); for all her practical knowledge, Maomao just doesn’t have the educational background for that.
But planted amongst all these scenes and a fair amount of humor are the seeds of this cour’s major plot lines. The tall, thin court lady is going to be a major player in one of them, and every detail shown about her so far is significant towards that end. The man wearing the monocle is also going to become a major player in another storyline, and the smoking pipe shown in the last scene will come into play either next episode or in episode 15, depending on the pacing. There may not have been more than hints of upcoming mysteries this episode, but expect plenty going forward.
Oh, and this episode introduces a new OP and ED. The OP gives a good sampling of the events that can be expected to come up in this cour (especially in closely-upcoming episodes), while the new, Jinshi-focused ED is a nice complement to the Maomao-focused first ED.
The second half is just getting started, so come back for more!
Welcome to my seasonal Guide! (For the debut schedule, see here.) I expect to cover every full-episode series that will be debuting this season and several of the sequels/returning series, including Tsukimichi -Moonlit Fantasy,Synduality: Noir, Mashle: Magic and Muscles, and Banished From The Heroes’ Party. (I may also cover the new Blue Exorcist installment, but we’ll see.) I will not be covering sequels for Classom of the Elite, Bottom-Tier Character Tomozaki, High Card, Kingdom, The Dangers in My Heart,Shaman King, and Fire Hunter, since I am not current on those franchises.
Debuts are listed below in oldest to newest order and may be added multiple times per day on busier days. Titles continuing from last season are not covered here.
NOTE: Turns out I’m not as caught up on Blue Exorcist as I thought, so I won’t be covering it here.
NOTE #2: The last expected entry for this Preview Guide is Meijin Gekki: 1874, on Sunday 1/14.
Meiji Gekken: 1874
Streams: Crunchyroll on Sundays
Rating: 4 (of 5)
This original series is a rarity among current anime titles: a true, dedicated historical drama. (Or, at the least, there’s no sign of a supernatural component within the first episode, though I did see one advertising picture which suggested that some may pop up later, a la My Happy Marriage.) It starts with the battle of Aizu Castle in 1868, whose eventual surrender was a key event in the Boshin War, before jumping forward to 1874, where a young former samurai named Shizuma, who was seen being a terror during the battle is now serving as a rickshaw runner as he looks for the little sister of a friend, who was to be his fiancee. He gets accused of involvement in an attempted assassination of a Japanese official due to one of his passengers, and in the process of clearing his name earns a recommendation into the police force from a police official.
That synopsis hardly covered everything going on in an episode so busy that it feels much longer than it is; in fact, the biggest knock against the episode is that it’s so busy that it’s hard to keep track of all of the threads. A turf war involving yakuza is involved, as are anti-Imperial plots, conniving foreign agents and their spies, and the circumstances of the fiancee Shizuma seeks. A relationship diagram may eventually be needed to keep track of who is connected to what, but the events shown here are deeply entrenched in actual history; some named officials were real people, and the assassination attempt of Tomomi Iwakura (who was most famous for leading a worldwide mission to study modern governments and economies with an eye to modernizing Japan) was an actual event. Technical merits aren’t bad and the detail work is impressive; this is a well-researched series. If your tastes include hard history, this one may be worth checking out.
Bang Brave Bang Bravern
Streams: Crunchyroll on Thursdays, beginning 1/18*
Rating: 4 (of 5)
Note: Crunchyroll will debut the first two episodes on 1/18. This review is based on an unofficial source.
We don’t get a truly bombastic mecha series even every year these days, which is why this original production is such a treat. Director Masami Obari has a long history with mecha titles (Detonator Orgun, Gravion, Secret Robot Wars OG: The Inspector) and it shows here in this gloriously over-the-top first episode.
The set-up is simple: Japanese and American forces are conducting joint training options (which, of course, include mecha) when apparent alien forces with overwhelming technical advantage attack. As things look their grimmest, a special, apparently sentient mecha arrives on the scene, invites one of the two featured mecha pilots inside it, then goes on a rampage against the invaders, all the while calling out dramatic attack names and playing theme music. (And we’re not just talking the OST; the pilot in question can hear it, too.)
The era where a mecha series can be a big breakout hit has passed, but in this one’s case, it isn’t for lack of effort. It features attempted camaraderie between an outgoing American pilot and a more reserved Japanese pilot, good-looking characters of both genders, and lots of visually appealing action scenes, including a suitable amount of tension when the chips are down. Most importantly, it has the necessary spirit and energy to succeed.
Bucchigiri?!
Stream: Crunchyroll on Saturdays
Rating: 3.5 (of 5)
I’ve never been a fan of semi-comedic series about brawling in a troubled high school setting, and so I probably won’t be following this original production, but I do have to acknowledge that this one is put together pretty darn well.
The story’s premise is basic: Arajin has transferred to a new high school that’s the lowest of the low, where gangs rule the scene and little real education happens. While getting intimidated by the gangsters, he bumps into an old friend who’s one of the local toughs and falls for a cute girl who turns out to be a gang leader’s sister who apparently likes to bait people into situations where her brother beats them up for getting to close to her. (Which, in retrospect, explains why she’s able to get away with looking so atypically cutesy in such a rough environment.) But then a genie shows up who’s connected to an old tradition of weaponless martial arts and makes a wish-based pact with Arajin at a crucial moment.
It’s all pretty silly, over-the-top stuff, but it’s delivered with a sharp, colorful visual flair, surprisingly good animation, and solid direction. The probably shouldn’t be a surprise, since it is directed and co-created by the director behind the similarly-impressive Sk8 the Infinity (as well as, interestingly, Free! and Banana Fish). It also has one of the most catchy EDs of the season, which is worth a watch even if you don’t bother with the episode. I could see this achieving a certain level popularity.
Snack Basue
Streams: Crunchyroll on Fridays
Rating: 2.5 (of 5)
In Japan, a “snack bar” is a kind of hostess club where female staff serve drinks to and flirt with male customers. While I didn’t have an opportunity to visit one in either of my trips to Japan, I have no doubt that the kind of inanity which goes on in them probably isn’t much different than what you’d find in a typical American bar. The operating premise of this comedy manga adaptation is that enough of those exchanges are humorous enough to make a vignette-based comedy series out of it. This first episode consists of two: one focusing on a businessman who has come to a snack bar for the first time (and thus provides an “in” for audiences who may be unfamiliar with the concept) and a second about a geeky guy who’s had no luck with the ladies but is still coming on hard to pretty junior hostess Akemi, while the would-be-motherly Basue watches and occasionally comments from the side.
Without a doubt, some of this is funny, which is why I’m giving this a mid-range rating. However, the presentation and style of the humor is definitely not aimed at the typical anime audiences, as the episode entirely lack anything visually dynamic. (The animation is limited, too.) That’s a barrier this series is just not going to be able to overcome in the States. Come in with low expectations and you might be entertained.
The Weakest Tamer Begins a Journey to Pick Up Trash
Streams: Crunchyroll on Fridays
Rating: 4 (of 5)
Wow, did this light novel adaptation come out of left field for me! I was certainly not expecting yet another story about an isekai main character taming slimes to look this good or have such a distinct emotional pull. While the episode’s hardly perfect, this one has at least some potential to be a true dark horse title for the season.
In this setting, a young girl flees her villages because she’s been proclaimed so useless that the village chief put a bounty on her head; she’s only got one Skill, and at the weakest possible rating. She’s determined to survive and strike out on her own, to the point of disguising herself as a boy and taking on a new name, and in the process meets a fragile little slime who’s as comparatively weak as she is. So of course the slime becomes her first successful tame.
As generic as that all sounds, the execution matters here. Visuals are sharp, detailed, and inviting, with unexpectedly strong animation backing them. The tale spun turns Ivy into a compelling character and invests serious effort into establishing the emotional connection she makes with the slime she calls Sora, but without getting overly schmaltzy. The gimmick with her talking to someone who’s presumed to be her memories from her past life may annoy some, but it didn’t bother me, and the musical support builds nicely throughout. The one legitimate knock is that Ivy takes a couple of minutes late in the episode to summarize information that can mostly be gleaned easily enough from implication and context, but even so this vastly exceed any expectations I had for this series. It’s worth checking out, even if isekai isn’t normally your thing.
The Witch and the Beast
Streams: Crunchyroll on Thursdays
Rating: 4 (of 5)
In the setting of this manga adaptation, a witch’s curse is one of the most powerful and intractable forms of magic. It can only be counteracted by the kiss of a true love, the witch changing her mind, or one other method that only works temporarily. A soft-spoken mage with a job to do (and a coffin on his back) and an apparent young woman with a bestial attitude and a score to settle have come to one particular city in search of the local witch, who’s regarded as a hero. But as the witch’s young helper learns the hard way, little is what it seems when witches are involved, and their grudges can run long and deep.
The title given for episode 2 in the Next Episode preview suggest that this is an in media res opening, but it still explains things well enough to allow viewers to understand what’s gong on and delivers on tone, character establishment, magic displays, and action. Long-time veteran VA Toshiyuki Morikawa is fantastic as the smooth-talking Ashaf, but the real winners here are the musical score and dramatic presentation. The delivery isn’t quite smooth enough to warrant a top-level grade; this one just hides its animation shortcuts better than most. Still, there’s plenty enough here to get enthused about, so this one will be a keeper.
Delusional Monthly Magazine
Streams: Crunchyroll on Thursdays
Rating: 2.5 (of 5)
A scientist who is researching a mysterious sunken continent that may or may not have existed (think Atlantis) has discovered an artifact from that continent and seeks to have a tabloid-like rag write about it since the regular scientific community won’t publish his work. But there may actually be a conspiracy keeping a lid on that investigation, and certainly some hoodlums are after the scientist. None of the mag’s staff may be normal, either; the dog seems a little too smart, the boy can heal, and the lackadaisical assistant editor both can sense that the scientist is cursed and winds up turning into a super-strong tiger man when he touches a relic.
Essentially, this original anime from studio OLM and the director of Raven of the Inner Palace seems to be a light, high-spirited “investigate weird stuff” kind of story, the kind that may even be meant to be accessible to younger viewers. The first episode establishes the premise and core cast well enough, but characters meant to be lovable come off more as annoying, the tone seems too cheery, and the animation effort is lackluster. Honestly I can’t see this one catching on with mainline anime fandom, and I see little here to merit watching more.
Cherry Magic! Thirty Years of Virginity Can Make You a Wizard?
Streams: Crunchyroll on Wednesday
Rating: 2.5 (of 5)
This is the anime version of a manga that has also been adapted into a live-action series, and after seeing the first episode, I have to wonder if that might be the preferable way to watch this. The gimmick here is that Adachi, who’s still a virgin at age 30, has suddenly gained the ability to read the minds of those he comes into physical contact with, and he accidentally finds out that male coworker Kurosawa has a thing for him. This starts making him incredibly self-conscious around Kurosawa, even as he starts to accept that Kurosawa is actually a good guy. The problem is that Adachi really isn’t ready for that kind of relationship, no matter what the gender is of the prospective partner.
And I will give the story credit for emphasizing that particular point: Adachi’s discomfort has everything to do with not wanting to take advantage of someone he knows like him and little to nothing to do with Kurosawa being a guy. Make either of these characters a woman, but keep the personalities essentially intact, and the play-out wouldn’t be much different. That said, there’s still a creep factor here that’s hard to overlook. I can see this developing into something stronger – and I’ve been assured by those familiar with the manga that this is the case – but I had a tough time sitting through this episode so I won’t be back.
Metallic Rouge
Streams: Crunchyroll on Wednesdays
Rating: 4 (of 5)
This original anime is effectively a 25th anniversary title for Studio Bones, and it is getting the deluxe treatment that might be expected from a studio with such a storied reputation. While not a mind-blowing spectacle, it still features some of the best production values and most impressive action sequences to date this season, all while firmly-establishing is tech noir ambiance and providing several potential plot hooks.
The story is hardly an original concept so far, borrowing heavily from Armitage III in setting and plot elements, Bubblegum Crisis in aesthetic style, and Blade Runner in many ways. In a future Mars where humans live alongside advanced androids called Neans, friction exists between the two. Rouge, a female Nean who goes by the name Metal Rouge in her armored form, is hunting down a special group of Nean called the Immortal Nine for as-yet-unrevealed reasons. She gets help in this from a human investigator named Naomi, and there’s also a drug(?) called Nectar involved, which is essential for the proper functioning of Neans. When a singer who’s taken Rouge in turns out to be one of the Immortal Nine trying to exit the organization and become just an ordinary singer, a battle erupts. Oh, and there’s a joker-like figure around.
The first episode doesn’t do the best job of laying out its circumstances, which is why I can’t rate this one higher. However, it is clearly a more adult-leaning title with a lot of promise and an awesome insert song (the one used in the series’ fantastic music video trailer). Definitely a keeper!
Sengoku Youko
Streams: Crunchyroll on Wednesdays
Rating: 3.5 (of 5)
A lot is apparently expected of this anime adaptation, as it has an unusual three-cour commitment up front and was among the most-anticipated new shows of the season. The first episode shows that the attention is not without reason. While it is hardly the sharpest-looking series out there, it still delivers well enough on its action, characters, and general spirit to be considered a success.
Part of the key to that is Tama, a fox spirit youko who is referred to as “elder sister” but looks like a kid and has a very child-like notion about justice mixed with some practical arguments that would be more expected from a much older individual. She’s clearly the heart of this Sengoku-era adventure, while her stepbrother, the misanthropic Jinka, is the enforcer. Shinusuke, a young swordsman seeking to make a name for himself, runs across them while investigating bandits and gets drawn to their supernatural supernatural conflicts. This involves multiple battle scenes, a transformation scene, and some entertaining exchanges amongst the three leads/ None of this is fresh or inspired, but the overall execution works so far.
Doctor Elise: The Royal Lady with the Lamp
Streams: Crunchyroll on Wednesdays
Rating: 3 (of 5)
This novel adaptation puts a somewhat unusual extra spin on the standard isekai concept: Elise was an Empress in her first life who got burned at the stake for as-yet-unspecified transgressions, which included the rest of her family being killed, too. In her new life in modern Japan, she diligently works to become an acclaimed surgeon in an effort to atone for the transgressions of her previous life, only to (apparently) die from injuries suffered in a plane crash. She then finds herself back in her original life, several years before her death. Or is this new opportunity just a fever dream as she lays comatose in the modern world?
While standard storytelling tactics suggests that this is a real second reincarnation, I’m not completing discounting that second possibility yet, as the situation seems too convenient. Regardless, this episode is just set-up for the overall plot thrust – i.e., that she will continue to use her medical knowledge in her redo of her original life – which will presumably get more fleshed out next episode, so this one is in a holding pattern for now. Despite the intriguing ideas afoot here, I can’t rate this one better because the medical drama aspect is too cheesy and some aspects of the way the plane scenes were animated felt too unnatural. Still, I’m not ruling out the possibility that this one could amount to something.
Villainess Level 99
Streams: Crunchyroll on Tuesdays
Rating: 3.5 (of 5)
I’ve always appreciated the rarely-used gimmick of starting a series with a complete fake-out, and this light novel adaptation does that more thoroughly than any title in years. Of course, the series’ name gives away the real truth of what the series is about. but here they even go as far as using a full opener indicating that the first half of the episode is what the series is actually about: a stereotypical otome game scenario about a commoner attending an elite academy on scholarship who collects a trio of hot guys around her on her path to eventually beating the Demon Lord. The actual protagonist, though, is an initial background character who’s secretly the story’s hidden ultimate villain. But this time around, she’s an isekai’d reincarnate who’s familiar with this game and wants no part in being the villain. Her efforts to stay inconspicuous and avoid the central quartet go up in flames, however, when an entrance level test reveal that years of level-grinding have unwittingly made her stupefyingly strong.
In other words, this is a cross between a standard isekai villainess scenario and I’ve Been Killing Slimes for 300 Years and Maxed Out My Level. What makes this both work and stand out a little is Yumiella’s utterly deadpan approach, one reminiscent of Mash in Mashle: Magic and Muscles, and the irony that the reveal of her high level is definitely going to interfere with the game’s intended path, just not at all in the way she intended. That combination gives the series enough of a spark to overcome the series’ weak use of CG and warrant watching more.
Synduality: Noir episode 13
Streams: Mondays on Hulu
Rating: 3.5 (of 5)
This series went into its seasonal break with the Silver Storm having been defeated but a passel of big mysteries floating around. The biggest and most obvious was, of course, that light-skinned, light-haired Noir had turned into a dark-skinned, dark-haired counterpart who called herself Mystere and referred to Noir as a “dud” and “safe mode.” Kanata taking Mystere around to various locations familiar to Noir does turn up a few interesting details, the most important of which is that Mystere was the Magus for Dr. Pascale, a name that has come up a couple of times before. By the end of the episode – and after briefly turning back into Noir – Mystere is suddenly enthused about going after Histoire.
Though I wasn’t impressed by this series at first, it turned into a fairly solid mecha action-drama series by the end of its first half. While the action components aren’t present in this episode, the episode still solidifies the already-firm foundation it had for its character development and more dramatic elements. I look forward to seeing more the hooks planted towards the end of the first season drawn in.
Hokkaido Gals are Super-Adorable!
Streams: Crunchyroll on Mondays
Rating: 3 (of 5)
This manga adaptation is defined by a central irony: a high school boy moves from Tokyo (the busiest and most worldly part of Japan) to the comparative backwater of Hokkaido, only to discover that his social life is is becoming more intense rather than more relaxed. That’s because curvaceous local gal-type Minami has quickly taken an interest in (and possibly liking to?) him. The result is a fairly standard “reserved boy is overwhelmed by the attention of a hot girl” scenario, with the only real variation being the setting. According to the OP and ED, at least two other girls will eventually become involved, too.
The whole scenario here hinges in part on Tsubasa not being able to get a read on Minami’s motivations. Is she just interested in him because he’s just something new in a place where there isn’t a lot to do, or does she genuinely like him? How much of what she’s doing is being innocently unaware of the effect she can have on young men vs. actually flirting and teasing? We’re seeing this entirely from Tsubasa’s view, so the only hint is that she did blush a bit when Tsubasa complimented her appearance. As run-of-the-mill as this all feels, the series does find some genuine humor in all of this, and Minami is hardly unlikable. I can’t see this series going anywhere big, but there’s just enough appeal here that it might be worth watching more.
The Foolish Angel Dances with the Devil
Streams: Crunchyroll on Mondays
Rating: 3 (of 5)
A demon sent from Hell to find someone to help rally the troops finds himself lovestruck at the sight of a girl who turns out to be an angel with a plan of her own – and some part of that plan involves turning the demon into a servant and having him help her with some task in exchange for sparing his life. This is the operating premise for this manga adaptation, and while the title may suggest that the devil (in this case Masatora) has the upper hand in their new relationship, events in the first episode strongly suggest otherwise. Up to the point where she reveals her true nature, he’s the one being overwhelmed by her cutesy charm, and even though he breaks her mystical chains once, she’s the one who utterly dominate their brief fight. That makes me curious about how this situation might turn around.
That and a decently convincing character design for the angel Lily are the two main things this debut has going for it and the reasons why I may watch another episode. This would normally be my type of romantic scenario, but the episode just spends too long setting itself up; what was done here could probably be accomplished in half an episode instead without losing much. I also find it baffling that someone who would be sent on a mission like that couldn’t better pick up on the unnatural allure of an angel. But hey, if the rest of the series plays out in entertaining fashion then I can overlook flaws like that. We’ll see what the next episode or two offers before I decide on this one.
‘Tis Time for “Torture,” Princess
Streams: Crunchyroll on Mondays
Rating: 2 (of 5)
The awards for both the Most Intriguingly Named and Most Misleadingly Named titles of the season go to this manga adaptation, which is about a warrior princess who has been captured and imprisoned (along with her sentient sword) by the Demon Army. The defining gag here is that the female torturer, unsubtly named Torture Tortura, is very good at what she does. She knows that the most effective torture has to be tailored to the subject, and in the princess’s case that means not physical abuse but gastronomic teasing. In other words, she tempts the princess with delectable foods in order to get her to spill secrets, creating a weird sort of foodie experience.
Some creative artistic effort aside, this approach has two crippling problems: it gets redundant all too quickly and some of the foodie gags are all too Japanese-specific. Using toast to sop up leftover gravy I can completely understand, but I’ve had takoyaki in Japan and it isn’t all that. The thing about late-night ramen and the side of rice left me scratching my head, too. And that’s without considering purely logical points, like why the sword is in the same cell with the princess. If she could slay that giant cyclops with that sword, she could certainly break out of a cell with it. Granted, someone (or in this case, something) has to be the straight man here, but even by the level of absurdity that this series is aiming for, that’s stretching it. The final pre-credit scene promises some new characters getting involved, but even with that and the joke in the epilogue I question the sustainability of the concept, too. While can appreciate what it’s trying to do, it’s a big miss for me.
Tsukimichi -Moonlit Fantasy- s2
Streams: Crunchyroll on Mondays
Rating: 3.5 (of 5)
Despite a very formulaic structure on paper (and in many was arguably derivative of That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime), the first season of this 2021 isekai power fantasy because of a combination of entertaining supporting characters, an exuberant spirit, and a few minor formula twists here and there. But it also left at least two major plot points hanging at the end – specifically, a gradually converging path towards Makoto meeting the other heros and his quest to learn more about the world. Dealing with both of those seems to be on tap as this new season begins. Makoto resumes his journey to the Academy, along the way winding up helping a village trouble by marauding bandits. Meanwhile, back in the demiplane, Rio is making some epically bad cooking efforts and Tomoe is seeing to the further training of new recruits.
Considering the chaos which typically reigned in the first season, this is a relatively mild start to the second. Even so, it still recaptures enough of the spirit of the first season to continue to be entertaining, and all of its little world-building quirks are still in play, and that’s all that matters. If you liked the first season, there’s no reason to have doubts about this one.
Pon no Michi
Streams: Nowhere legal on Fridays
Rating: 2.5 (of 5)
This original series, from the director of The Vexations of a Shut-In Vampire Princess, has, curiously, not been picked up for U.S. streaming as of this writing despite being a full-length episode and being neither a kids’ show nor a racy one. (All of the girls introduced so far have very distinct figures, but the first episode has nothing I’d count as fan service.) It features high school student Nashiko, who has to find a new place to hang out after she gets kicked out of her house for being too boisterous. Her father allows she and her friends to use a closed-down, standalone mahjong parlor which was apparently just being used for storage, provided that they clean it up. The girls decided to use it as their new hangout – and oh, yes, there’s a sparrow who professes to be a “mahjong spirit” whom only Nashiko can hear talk.
The first episode gives the impression that this will be a casual series where the girls can get together and be goofy, while also delving into how mahjong is played. It uses several visual parodies, mostly I believe of the gambling-focused franchise Kaiji, and has an enthusiastic fourth girl who shows up at the end, eager to play. (A fifth girl is shown in both the OP and ED but hasn’t appeared yet.) This is definitely not one of the prettier-looking series of the season, and that’s a big mark against this one. Its character design aesthetic also leans more towards sexy than cute, but, again, with no eye to fan service so far. Overall, I don’t see this one having a lot of appeal if you’re not into its featured game, but it does, at least, have energy in its facor.
Mr. Villain’s Day Off
Streams: Crunchyroll on Sundays
Rating: 2.5 (of 5)
In recent years, there have been a few humorous send-ups of super sentai team tropes, including excellent ones like Love After World Domination and good ones like Miss Kuroitsu From the Monster Development Department. Based on the first episode, this one is the least of that lot. Its particular take is to focus on one of the leading villains and how he enjoys his days off from trying to wipe out humanity. He’s become addicted to panda cuteness, so he’ll make sure to allow them to breed more freely once humanity is gone, and he has strict standards about not interacting with coworkers or fighting on off days, so he is trying to establish a proper work/rest mental attitude.
Some of this is definitely funny, but there are two problems here which prevent a higher rating. Once is the pacing; rather than more rapid-fire jokes, these are drawn our, making me wonder if this concept might have worked better in a short format. The other is that the series cannot sustain on Mr. Villain (and the hapless Red Ranger) alone. It’s going to need to quickly expand its cast. Fortunately the latter problem, at least, is easily surmountable, as other characters are shown in the OP. Still, this one isn’t a keeper unless its second episode does much better.
7th Time Loop: The Villainess Enjoys a Carefree Life Married to Her Worst Enemy
Streams: Crunchyroll on Sundays
Rating: 3 (of 5)
Few series more completely or succinctly describe their gimmick and operating premise with their title than this one does. The only real twist in this first episode is how Rishe, a young woman who had her engagement to the crown prince of her nation annulled by that prince, winds up marrying the man who was either directly or indirectly responsible for her death five years later (in six previous runs through ages 15 to 20), not that it happens. The one other potentially interesting factor here is how this might change her future prospects, as it’s entirely possible that having a good woman at his side might have kept Arnold Hein, the crown prince of an empire, from becoming the warmonger which got Rishe killed the last few times.
While the end result is easily anticipated, the path there has at least some merits. A fortuitous encounter in Rishe’s first go-through showed her that she had broader options in life, and in each new attempt she enthusiastically pursued a new path, rather than just try to repeat and tweak previous events. This accumulation of knowledge and skills leaves her stronger each time, to the point that she can catch the dour future Emperor’s eye; he seems the type more impressed by ability than beauty. That makes Rishe a suitably strong character for this kind of situation. The reason I’m not rating this higher, though, is that something about the art style – particularly in the way eyes are drawn – does not set right with me, and that’s a potentially major barrier for me. It may bother other viewers less, and so should be a more promising candidate for others.
Banished from the Hero’s Party s2
Streams: Crunchyroll on Sundays
Rating: 3.5 (of 5)
Banished was one of 2021’s most pleasant surprises, and Red and Rit were my pick for Duo or Couple of the Year for 2021, so this one’s return after a couple of years off is quite welcome indeed, especially since the last episode of season 1 did leave a couple of plot points hanging. I recommend reviewing that last episode before watching this one, as some of what’s going on here directly spins off of things going on there. Certainly not the least of that is the reappearance of the elf druid Yarandrala, who was seen in flashbacks in the first season. However, the reappearance of Theodora (now masquerading as the masked knight Esta) is just as significant, especially since she’s in the role of guiding Van of Flamberge, a prince of a fallen kingdom who’s the new Hero. But after seeing how Ruti became consumed with that role, can she successfully guide Van away from that trouble, especially he seems to be much more of a religious fanatic?
In other words, the lingering sense that the god Demis may not have the best intentions hasn’t gone away, but the more immediate concern for the rest of the returning cast is a trade mission to the gem giants, where Red intends to barter for a proper stone for Rit’s wedding ring. It’s mostly pleasant in the same way that much of the first season was, although there are starting to be hints of impending complications beyond just Yarandrala’s reappearance. All of that contributes to a satisfying start to the season. The one weird thing, though, is how the OP focuses almost exclusively on Ruti, and between that and the regular episode the camera seems more intent on ogling her (including some undefined nudity in the OP). This isn’t a problem for me, as Ruti is more my preferred physical type than Red is, but it seems strange to focus on her so much when the first episode isn’t. Still, that’s more a curiosity at this point than a problem.
Mashle: Magic and Muscles s2 (ep 13)
Streams: Crunchyroll on Saturdays
Rating: 3 (of 5)
Mash Burnedead is back to deal with the fallout from the first season’s end in his own unique way. This time, though, the stakes have escalated, for rumor is spreading about his lack of ability to use magic. And while some rules sticklers want to see him executed for that, others have taken interest in him for what he can do – for better or worse.
Really, the first episode back is just par for the course for the series, with Mash doing magic-like feats through sheer brawn, strange new characters popping up, and previous associates just hanging out. It still has a couple of standard sputter-worthy moments, but overall, the attempts at humor didn’t feel quite as sharp as was commonly-seen in the first season. Overall, it’s not a bad return, but not an especially exciting one, either.
Solo Leveling
Streams: Crunchyroll on Saturdays
Rating: 2.5 (of 5)
This one is based on a manhwa that’s supposedly one of the hottest properties in fandom right now, so this is one of the season’s biggest debuts. After seeing the first episode, I’m not sure why. While its technical merits are pretty decent, it’s not a spectacle like Chainsaw Man‘s debut was, nor does it have the gorgeous visuals and compelling drama of the Demon Slayer debut. There’s nothing special about the premise, either; in fact, it’s very derivative of other works about magically-empowered individuals fighting off threats from another world, with a bit of RPG-styled dungeon crawling thrown in. Sure, it’s on the graphic side, but other titles which have debuted this season have been at least this graphic. Protagonist Jinwoo (Crunchyroll is apparently keeping the original Korean names) has not shown anything special by the end of the episode, either; he’s just an ordinary bottomfeeder trying to scrape by for his family, with his only redeeming quality being that a mildly pretty healer seems to like him. Whatever gimmick is supposed to turn him into something special is beyond the scope of this episode.
In fact, this is one series that probably should have had a double-length debut, as it doesn’t feel like we’ve gotten anywhere near the defining premise by the end of the first episode. I’ll watch another episode or two to see how the actual premise plays out and see if that changes my mind, but so far I’m missing the hype boat here.
A Sign of Affection
Streams: Crunchyroll on Saturdays
Rating: 4.5 (of 5)
This manga adaptation is not my kind of series, so I probably won’t end up following it, but damned if it didn’t still impressed me enough that I have to give it a strong recommendation. I could even see this one being a bit emotional for some viewers.
In it, Yuki is a typical college student, except for the fact that she’s deaf. One day on a train she’s helped out by Itsuomi, a tall, handsome college student who’s a club mate of her best friend, and is startled into her first budding crush when he doesn’t seem thrown off in the least by her impairment. Rin’s interested in Itsuomi’s cousins, so the two support each other in getting the contact info for their interests, an exercise which has the potential to expand Yuki’s world greatly once she gets over her anxieties.
That plot may not sound like much, but the execution really matters here, and director Yuta Murano (Kakushigoto) fully delivers on that, including using three animators assigned just to getting the sign language parts right (though most communication is done through phones). All of the character designs are finely-detailed and gorgeously-rendered, but watching Yuki’s expressiveness is a particular delight; it’s not hard to understand why Itsuomi (and maybe others, too) might become enchanted with her, as there’s something positively magical about her expression of joy when Itsuomi messages to her, “let me into your world.” Great feels, a likable heroine, and effective use of light humor all add up to an impactful start.
The Strongest Tank’s Labyrinth Raids
Streams: Crunchyroll on Saturdays
Rating: 2.5 (of 5)
Fantasy stories about characters who have been kicked out of their party or organization because their talents and/or abilities were misunderstood and underappreciated have become practically their own subgenre in recent years; one of the most prominent ones, Banished From The Heroes’ Party, is even returning later this season. This appears to be another of that ilk, with defensive specialist Rud being kicked from the Hero’s party because his defensive abilities seem inefficient. The only minor twist here is that only the Hero is being an ass about it; the rest of his party that has adventured with Rud is much more sympathetic, and at least one even seems to be romantically interested in him. Naturally, Rud finds his way temporarily with another young party before encountering a girl (an illegally-created homunculus) who reassures him that his skills make him even more valuable to his party than he realized. Oh, and he’s a siscon with a young sister who’s incurable by normal means.
This one doesn’t seem like it’s going to be a fan service title, which is good, because both the girl Luna and many of the others shown in the OP look very young. It’s also a non-isekai fantasy which still operates on game mechanics (as most series of these types do) and doesn’t offer anything interesting in the monster or fight design categories. Rud is pleasingly good-natured, Luna is suitably cute (if also utterly generic in design), and the business about homunculi (which are used as slave labor in this setting) seems like a potentially interesting angle, but I just don’t see much here to hold interest.
Tales of Wedding Rings
Streams: Crunchyroll on Saturdays
Rating: 3 (of 5)
I hadn’t looked at any advertisements for this manga adaptation, so based on the title I was expecting a more pure romantic series, maybe even an anthology. Nope; the first episode (and especially its OP and sexy ED) make it clear that this is going to be a fan service-laden harem isekai series. Protagonist Satou has a human princess bound to him with a wedding ring by the end of the first episode, and it looks like four other hotties from diverse races will eventually join him, the Ring King, too.
This all comes about because the blonde foreigner that Satou has been friends with for a decade, Himeno, isn’t a princess just in name (Hime = princess) and attitude; she actually is a princess from another world who had been hiding out in modern Japan for her own protection. Satou was at the point of confessing to her when she left to return to her world to get married, so he followed her, and in a moment of crisis, got a kiss, a ring, a wife, a title, and a lot of responsibility to fight demonic creatures out of it. But if it’s all for Hime and what’s important to her. . .
Honestly, this title has some factors stacked against it. Its animation is less than stellar, its male character designers are basic and unappealing, and it is heavy on stereotypical story elements. However, what save the opener is that Satou, despite being anxious about the situation, does man up when he needs to. His feelings about Hime clearly run deeper than just her cleavage (which is saying something!), and he responds when he sees desperate soldiers all looking to him for what he can do – which is, essentially, turn any weapon he handles into a magical one capable of destroying demons in one hit. I’m not expecting greatness out of this one, but between that and the fan service (including just a touch of nudity), it actually feels watchable.
The Demon Prince of Momochi House
Streams: Crunchyroll on Friday
Rating: 2.5 (of 5)
The set-up is in many ways very reminiscent of Kamisama Kiss: a teen girl on her own, with nowhere else to go, ends up at an isolated structure that she can claim as her own and encounters there supernatural bishonen, including one with animal ears. Despite initial attempts to push her away, and some element of personal danger, she ends up living there with said bishonen. And she may well have some powers of her own – though, curiously, none of the bishonen comment on that despite one clearly having a run-in with it. That’s about where the similarities end, though, because one of the bishonen is the spiritual contractor, not the MC herself.
This is definitely playing to the same audience that went gaga over KamisamaKiss, though, so if you are familiar enough with that title to have a reaction to it, then you’ll probably have a similar reaction here. Certain aspects of it do look good – especially the mulicolored robe that Aoi wears – and the character designs are pleasing enough, but nothing about the set-up stands out, and Aoi is, frankly, too nice in his normal form. I just don’t see this one having a very broad appeal.
The Wrong Way to Use Healing Magic
Streams: Crunchyroll on Fridays
Rating: 4 (of 5)
Honestly, I’m shocked that I am rating this light novel adaptation this high. It certainly isn’t going to be one of the better-looking series this season, and for the first few minutes it’s mostly as bland and generic a “random guy gets caught up in an isekai summoning not intended for him” scenario as can be imagined, with Ken Usato being the ordinary guy beside school stand-outs like Class President Suzune Inukami and VP Kazuki Ryusen, who were the “accomplished people” targeted by the summoning. Then, after they’re summoned to the throne room of the fantasy world and go through the standard “defeat the Demon King” spiel, the screws gradually start popping out. That’s when the debut starts to show real promise as a fun little jaunt.
For starters, the Class President isn’t the expected straight person here. She’s actually as isekai-crazed as any chunibyou geek, and the expressions of glee she shows off (and Usato’s reactions to them) seem so against type that they’re fun to watch. The reaction of everyone to learning that Usato has the very rare healing magic is also what you’d more expect from a pure comedy show, as is Rose and her Recovery Team minions. In other words, this seems more like more a comedy-laced romp than a pure action-oriented isekai, and the series is better for it. I’m getting a good vibe off of this one, and will certainly be watching at least a bit more of it.
The Undead Unwanted Adventurer
Streams: Crunchyroll on Fridays
Rating: 3.5 (of 5)
The title on this light novel adaptation is very straightforward about what the series is: an average-ability adventurer gets in over his head, dies, and discovers that he’s still around as a sentient undead. Naturally, this creates some serious complications for MC Rentt, not the least of which is that he can’t walk back into town as a skeleton. Ironically, though, this may actually be his ticket to getting stronger after being stalled at a low level for many years, because undead, like other monsters, can evolve into stronger forms. He also has a sexy sage friend who might find his predicament very interesting indeed, since monster evolution is one of her fields of study. But first he has to evolve into a ghoul and figure out how to talk as an undead.
This one feels like it might have some promise, as it doesn’t hand-wave practical considerations like whether or not Rentt can even talk in his undead forms. Some hooks are also built in to provide reason to make connections to various female characters, leading to the potentially amusing irony that he may wind up doing better with the ladies as an undead than he did while alive. There’s also the mystery of why he’s fully sentient in his state. Unlike predecessor Skeleton Knight in Another World, this one isn’t an isekai, and it seems to be playing things straight rather than humorously so far, but the animation looks pretty good. Not expecting a lot out of this one, but it’s not trash, either.
Sasaki and Peeps
Streams: Crunchyroll on Fridays
Rating: 2.5 (of 5)
A lot is going on in the first episode of this light novel adaptation, which may be why it has a double-length debut. In fact, I’d even say that too much is going on here, as the series is distinctly trying to meld a “freely travel between the two worlds” isekai with a modern-world supernatural investigations story. Eventually, the two aspects are going to clash. But perhaps that’s the point
The titular Sasaki is a 39-year-old single guy who’s dependable but only satisfied with his job because he knows it could be worse. He’s got a thing for cute animals, so a pet store visit lead to him getting a pet bird, who turns out to be a reincarnated wizard from another world. Turns out Sasaki has an affinity for the magic “Peeps” teaches him, and with Peeps’ help he makes money on the side by jaunting over to the wizard’s original world. Then he discovers that people with magic-like psychic powers do exist in his world and they’re government-related, and he’s mistaken for one and gets pulled into that line of work. There’s also an over-enthusiastic female would-be partner in the psychic investigations, a possibly-scheming new boss, and a teenager neighbor girl who might be interested in him, too. What’s a mild-mannered guy like Sasaki to do?
I will give the series credit for throwing out a ton of potential hooks, including the neighbor girl having a less-than-stellar family situation, but again, it feel like it’s trying to do too much and not being much more than bland at any of them. Very average technical merits are also a negative, but seeing a series like this focus on an adult character is gratifying. I don’t feel like this one’s a keeper, but I may give it another episode or two.
My Instant Death Ability is Overpowered
Streams: HIDIVE on Thursdays
Rating: 1 (of 5)
Based on the title, I wasn’t expecting much from this light novel adaptation, but I am still shocked at how poorly this debut under-performs even my low expectations.
This is what I call a “spirited away” style isekai, where a bus on a field trip gets transported to another world by seemingly-young woman who’s looking for new “sages,” so she casually kills the teacher and driver for trying to interrupt her and gives most of the class video game-like displays and powers and a task to perform. The rest of the class callously leaves the four who didn’t get powers behind as bait for a dragon, but hey, one of those (who slept through the whole thing) seems to already have an instant-death ability, and he’s not shy about using it, except on one of the girls left behind with him because she’s got nice boobs. Oh, and a trio of other students have previously been isekai’d to this world, but they’re just complete asses who exist only so the MC can show off his power on unsympathetic targets. A slave collar and planned necrophilia are also involved, and somehow at least some of this is supposed to be funny, too.
I’d call this first episode tone-deaf, but even that isn’t adequate to describe how badly this comes together. The MC comes off as a complete sociopath, but the classmates who all just blandly accept leaving a few of their own as dragon bait aren’t any better, and the time frames involved make little sense. So do the motives and behavior of this “sage” character, whom the series is trying to pass off as a villain who comes across as a nice person. Add in mediocre technical merits and a complete inability to convey a desired tone and you have one of the worst debut episodes I’ve seen in quite a while.
Chained Soldier
Streams: HIDIVE on Thursdays
Rating: 3 (of 5)
When HIDIVE announced that this manga adaptation was going to stream uncensored, I expected a more graphic and/or tawdry debut than what we get here. I’m told that the fan service in this one gradually ratchets up as the series progresses, so this a relatively tame start may not be typical. Of course, the premise alone – the girl can make the boy her empowered slave, but she has to reward him for it, and in this case she’s been compelled into sexual behavior – is all kinds of wrong, so that will have to sustain for now.
Essentially, the setting is a modern world where only females can get special powers from a fruit found in another world which occasionally converges, and the ones who get the most combat-oriented powers become part of a corps who retrieves civilians who get transported to the desolate, monster-ridden alternate world. Naturally, why these are all teen-aged (or younger!) girls is a trivial detail, but one of the strongest among them – the swordswoman Kyoka – rescues the boy Yuki when he gets spirited away, then in a moment of desperation make him her slave, which works out so well that Yuki gets recruited to be a slave in combat and housekeeper for the girls on Kyoka’s team outside of it, something he has understandably mixed feelings about.
“Mixed” is my reaction to this, too. The action scenes aren’t bad, the character designs are plenty appealing, and the fetishy aspect of all of this doesn’t bother me. However, the overall look and color scheme aren’t inviting, and the beginning of the episode is clumsily handled at best. It’ll take another episode or two to see if this one will amount to anything.
Delicious in Dungeon
Streams: Netflix on Thursdays
Rating: 3.5 (of 5)
I have read most of the source manga that has been translated into English for this one, and long felt it would adapt well as an anime, so this was my most-anticipated debut of the season. It’s not a spectacular debut, but it mostly doesn’t disappoint, either.
The premise isn’t complicated: the priestess from a dungeon-crawling party consisting of human knight Laios, elven mage Marcille, and halfling rogue Chilchuck (and two members who got recruited by other parties!) got eaten by a dragon, and they have to get her body back before she gets fully digested. (The first episode doesn’t clarify this, but anyone who dies in the dungeon can be resurrected relatively easily as long as the body is mostly intact.) Short on funds, Laios declares that they’ll just have to live off the land on their quest – in other words, eat dungeon monsters, much to the dismay of Marcille. Fortunately, they run into the dwarf Senshi, who’s made a life of being a dungeon gourmet, and he agrees to join them.
In other words, this is as much a cooking show as it is a dungeon crawl, with recipes using ingredients like slimes, mushroom men, scorpions, and the fruit of carnivorous plants. At this stage it’s as much a comedy, too, with the first episode holding a number of funny moments. (Laios’s guilty expression when Marcille accuses him of ulterior motives with this plan is classic.) The visual presentation, courtesy of studio Trigger, is more brightly colorful than one might expect for a dungeon crawl but looks good, and the animation so far is solid but hasn’t been challenged much yet. It’s a faithful adaptation, too, except for not posting the full recipes on-screen. I don’t feel I can rate it any higher because something – the pacing, maybe – is just a bit off, but I can assure you that what you see in the first episode is what most of the series will be, so this is one case where you’ll know by the end of the first episode if this one is a keeper or not. I may episode-review it myself if nothing else grabs my attention more.
Ishura
Streams: Hulu on Wednesdays
Rating: 3.5 (of 5)
The first episode of this one doesn’t tell you much about what the series will actually be, since it mostly features a magic student watching as a friend gets ripped apart by a small golem and then a big golem, combined with a horde of small golems, thoroughly trashing her home city. Afterwards, a young man who’s a Visitor (i.e., from a different world) arrives and defeats the massive golem with style. The narration at the end and the OP suggest that this fellow is just one of many who will play prominent roles in what I’m assuming is going to be a very expansive story, and that this is not only just a character introduction episode, but just the first of a few of them.
Whatever the case, this one features an ambitious animation effort and at least one scene of very graphic content. The female lead deciding to help the sword-wielding dude in order to lead him to people who can take him out, rather than out of gratitude, was also an interesting little twist. While the musical choices are less than stellar, the visuals and that little twist may be good enough to carry the series until the story firms up more.
Gushing Over Magical Girls
Streams: HIDIVE on Wednesdays
Rating: 3.5 (of 5)
The first thing to know about this series is that HIDIVE successfully got the uncensored version, and in this case, that really matters. It takes less than three minutes for the first transformation scene involving detailed nudity to pop up, and the costume of Utena (pictured in the screenshot) literally has large pasties for frontal coverage. That’s just for starters in what is easily one of the raciest and kinkiest debut episodes in recent memory.
But it’s not just about the fan service. There are some genuinely funny moments, too (the plant creature with the S&M-styled apparel, the way the magical girls react the next day to their thorough spankings), and Utena quickly proves that her mascot wasn’t off the mark in choosing her to be a villain; what she believed was adoration for magical girls apparently has much more fetishy roots than Utena realized, and she doesn’t (yet) want to accept that she transforms into an S&M mistress for a reason. There’s also the curious (and probably not idle) detail that Utena’s transformation command is exactly the same as that of the magical girls. This series definitely isn’t for everyone, and I definitely wouldn’t recommend it for those who are fans of more pure-hearted magical girl series, if your tastes run toward the less prurient side, check this one out.
Fluffy Paradise
Streams: Crunchyroll on Mondays?
Rating: 3 (of 5)
The set-up is is only a slight variation on a standard isekai set-up: an overworked 27-year-old office drone collapses and dies, only to be recruited by a god to be reborn in a new world to evaluate whether or not the humanity of that world deserves to continue. To bribe her to undertake this task, the god gives her an ability of her choice. She just wants to pet all kinds of fluffy animals, so she’s given the ability to be liked by “creatures other than humans.” In her new life as the toddler daughter of a duke, that means animals of all types are attracted to her, even the sacred holy beasts. (She’s riding one in the screenshot.) But will it extend to dragons, too?
Other than the set-up, this episode is mostly about protagonist Nefertima meeting a prince and king, learning a bit about the world, and of course enjoying the bliss of petting animals. There could be a story here in how her ability could have vastly broader implications once it’s recognized, and the OP suggests that there may be some eventual action elements, but so far this looks like a low-key isekai more about having fun than about having grand adventures. And that’s okay; slice-of-life isekai titles have been proven to work. Nothing exciting about the artistry so far, but this seems like a pleasant enough series overall.
As we say good-bye to 2023, it’s time to take a look at the highlights of the year as a whole, rather than just individual seasons.
And my, this was a very full year, with over 190 series either debuting or getting new installments this year! The Fall 2023 season was the biggest and deepest I can remember from all of my years of anime reviewing, but the good stuff to be had this year is not even close to limited to just that season. In fact, the field this year is problematically deep, as a plethora of series are plenty good and/or entertaining enough to merit mention, but they just don’t make the cut against stronger competition.
So what was good enough in my book? Let’s take a look!
The Top Ten Series for 2023
In 2022’s edition of this exercise, I remarked that the field of worthy candidates was very deep for the the #9 and 10 positions. This year, the field is deep for all positions. Any of the titles in the #2-5 spots could be Series of the Year in many other years in the past decade, and most of the titles in the #6-10 slots would be top 5 titles in many others years. And this is despite widely-lauded fare like Vinland Saga and Scott Pilgrim Takes Off not being among titles considered here. (I tried to watch the latter, but couldn’t even finish the first episode.)
Series of the Year – Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End
This was actually a fairly close call over the #2 pick, as both series excelled similarly well at the characterizations and themes they were working with (even if those characterizations and themes were as different as could be). Both also had stellar musical throughout, delivered a number of powerful and emotional scenes, and stood far from the norm for their respective genres on the gimmicks they used and storytelling approaches they took. The difference-makers here are that the technical merits are a little better and the use of a singularly uniting theme gives a greater sense of a cohesive whole, despite the episodes so far mostly being individual vignettes.
In general, though, this is just a great series, easily one of the finest fantasy titles anime has ever animated. It spins a compelling, very different tale about an essentially-immortal elf who was the wizard in the party of the Hero who defeated the Demon King, but thanks to centuries of isolation which caused her to lose any social perspective, she did not appreciate how much the time she spent with that party (and particularly Himmel, the hero) meant to her until decades later, after the Hero passed on. In retracing her previous journey with new companions, she gradually comes to understand what transpired before. No series I’ve ever seen explores so deeply and thoroughly what it truly means to be ageless, and each episode offers up numerous little thematic joys and even tidbits of rather funny humor. And on the rare times it engages in action, it can deliver on that, too.
2. Oshi no Ko – It started out with a twisty, turny, emotional powerhouse of an extra-length first episode and features one of the biggest anisongs ever as an OP, but that’s far from all the series has going for it. Dramatic twists and turns are the name of the game as the story focuses on twin reincarnates forging their way into the entertainment industry after the murder of their idol mother. The girl, Ruby, seeks to follow in her mother’s footsteps to better understand her mother, while the boy, Aqua, seeks out their unknown father for revenge, since he believes that man has to be behind their mother’s murder (and his own as well in his previous life). Following those lines, the series delves deeply into the sometimes-dark realities of various aspects of the entertainment industry and deeply analyzes the mindsets of those involved and how they can be shaped by the industry. Episode 6, “Egosurfing,” is a devastating look at how social media lambasting can drive a person to suicide, but the series offers plenty of other strong, timely critiques, too. The series hits too many points too strongly to be denied.
3. Pluto – Boy, am I glad I took the time out from the busy Fall season to watch this eight-hour Netflix adaptation of Naoki Urasawa’s lauded manga spin-off of Astro Boy. At heart, this well-animated series is a murder-mystery where robots are among the victims, culprits, and investigators, but it aims so much higher than that, making scathing commentary on the Iraq War and the broader impact of war in general, especially the way former soldiers integrate back into society (or not). It is intense, dramatic, and philosophical, and delivers quite well on the action front, too.
4. The Apothecary Diaries – I love this series so much that it pains me to rank it this low, but its competition in 2023 is just that steep. Its story about a young apothecary who grew up in a red light district getting kidnapped and sold into the Rear Palace of a Chinese imperial-styles Emperor finds exactly the right balance of humor, mystery, drama, and social commentary for my tastes, all while swimming in a wealth of fine, well-researched visual and storytelling detail. Certainly doesn’t hurt that it features one of my favorite characters in recent memory, either.
5. Attack on Titan Final Season THE FINAL CHAPTERS – There were two installments of it in 2023, so I think its counts as a series rather than a movie. The ending has been hugely controversial – even some long-time AoT fans hate it – but these two parts, totaling 145 minutes of animation, deliver some of the most spectacularly dramatic action content in recent memory and a number of devastatingly powerful moments as Eren’s former friends and allies gradually realize that saving or redeeming Eren isn’t really an option anymore. These final episodes have all of the subtlety of a sledgehammer on the points they’re pushing, and there is a certain messiness to this, but the story climaxes in exactly the way it has to. I also loved the at-first sweet, then later damning, nature of the epilogue which plays out during the credits of the second episode. Like it or hate it, this content has impact, and that has to be respected.
6.Undead Murder Farce – My pick for the top series of the Summer ’23 season sadly only makes it this high, but it looks like it’s being honored in at least a couple of Anime News Network Top 5 lists, so I feel less bad about putting it this low. Although the series sometimes gets a little too talky for its own good, and doesn’t have quite as strong a start as many other titles on this list do, it still satisfyingly delivers on its supernaturally-themed mysteries and occasional dry sense of humor in both visual and dramatic senses, all while poking in a number of classic literary references. (Sherlock Holmes, Arsene Lupin, and Frankenstein’s monster all make appearances, for instance.) It features lots of entertaining story twists and one of the year’s most enjoyable supporting characters (the half-ogre Tsugaru) as well.
7. The Ancient Magus’ Bride s2 – If I was rating this series just on its last six or seven episodes, it would be in the Top 5. The slow but necessary burn to set up the drama of the last few episodes holds the series back in an overall rating, however. Even so, Philomela’s character development arc is still one of the year’s best, and later episodes in particular recapture the wondrous and sometimes dark nature of magic which made the first season so appealing. The series also deserves kudos for effectively instituting a very-necessary great expansion of its cast while still allowing its established stars a wealth of further development opportunities, too.
8.The Magical Revolution of the Reincarnated Princess – This one was actually my top pick for the Winter ’23 season, so it feels criminal to put it this low in the order. Still, this tale of Anisphia (a rambunctious princess born without magic but with a talent for developing the new, item-based “magicology”) and Euphyllia (a gifted duke’s daughter rescued from a bind by Anisphilia after her engagement to the prince was annulled by the prince) is still a compelling, very different take on the standard isekai formula, one which features beautiful character designs, great character development, and an unequivocal yuri relationship at its core. Watching them grow towards each other and overcome difficulties to become a mutually-supportive couple is a pure delight even if you’re not a yuri fan.
9. Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon? IV p2 – Might be playing just a little favoritism here with this pick, but I also truly do think that the second half of season 4 is this good. The dramatic boss battle waged by the rest of Bell’s party against the Amphisbaena, and the way that party proves that it can stand and defeat a difficult foe without Bell, is no slouch, but the real strength comes from the travails of Bell and Ryu as they have to go into Survival Mode in the Dungeon’s Deep Levels. It also allows the pain, loss, self-recrimination, and revenge which forms Ryu’s tragic past to come out in powerful fashion as both she and Bell grow from the experience. Also features some of the year’s best action sequences.
10.The Eminence in Shadow(eps 14-32) – The other two titles most seriously considered for this slot were the more conventional (if also ultimately magical) My Happy Marriage and the very weird Heavenly Delusion, but I ultimately settled on this one partly because I regret not forcing it into my list last year and partly because it’s the one which entertained me the most of the three; I’ve rewatched episodes of it multiple times, but the same isn’t true for the other two. Yes, it’s a reincarnation isekai about an OP protagonist, but I love how rich with irony it is, the way protagonist Cid/Shadow views everything a grand stage and make-believe while the rest of his organization takes it almost too seriously. It finds a great balance between bloody violence, stylish drama, sexy fan service, and (sometimes darkly-shaded) humor and has the most absorbing ambiance of any title on this list. There are some weak points in this run of episodes, which is why I can’t rate it higher, but the strengths more than balance those out.
Individual Awards
Character of the Year – Maomao, The Apothecary Diaries
There were several other good options here. Oshi no Ko‘s Kana Arima impressed me by turning from an annoying brat in episode 1 to a surprisingly well-developed an interesting cynic over the course of the series, Tsugaru from Undead Murder Farce was a delight as the lackey who disguised his true skills behind the mask of a lackadaisical idiot, the titular character from Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End impressed more and more as the season progressed and her character filled out, Mia from Tearmoon Empire proved much more charming than expected, and even Rentaro from The 100 Girlfriends deserves mention for being absolutely genuine about intending to fully love all six of his girlfriends to date. However, none of them can top this lovable little freak. Sure, she’s a coolly-capable and unflaggingly-pragmatic apothecary and mystery solver, but she she also delights in testing out new poisons on herself and actually relishes the job of being a poison tester. The catlike way she brushes off the too-gorgeous and too-interested Jinshi, the way she gives sexual advice even to Imperial consorts, and the way she just loses it when she gets access to something she loves all endear her to the viewer, as does the way she tackles much weightier matters, like essentially consigning a lady-in-waiting to execution by convincing her that the only way to prevent her crimes from tainting her beloved mistress is to confess to them. A stellar Japanese performance by Aoi Yuki certainly doesn’t hurt, either.
Duo or Couple of the Year – Bell and Ryu, Is It Wrong To Try To Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon? 4
This was a much harder pick, as there were several good options in 2023 but none that stood out. Others worth considering include Saku and Yukichi (the cat) from The Masterful Cat Is Depressed Again Today, Euphyllia and Anisphia from The Magical Revolution of the Reincarnated Princess (my runner-up pick), Koito and Elda from Otaku Elf, Lammis and Boxxo from Reborn as a Vending Machine, I Now Wander the Dungeon, and yes, Pig and Jess from Buteraba. However, I went with this (mostly) non-romantic duo because of how effectively they learn to work together as a team when isolated from any reasonable hope of support and the way each comes off better for it; Ryu helps coach the talented but still inexperienced newbie and reassure with with her calm confidence, while Bell helps the veteran come to terms with how her former familia getting wiped out has long haunted her. Neither would have survived to come home without the other.
Scene of the Year: Ai tells Aqua and Ruby “I Love You,”Oshi no Ko episode 1
Ai’s life and career were so thoroughly based on lies that she feared to say “I love you” to her twins because she wasn’t sure she could say it without those words being as empty as when she sang those lyrics on stage. But when it really, really counted the most, she was able to do it and knew that she meant it. From the moment I first saw this scene, this award was locked in. There were some other scenes that may have been worthy of being considered in other years – Ryu defeating the Juggernaut with the help of the spirits of Astrea Familia in DanMachi4 episode 22, Akane taking on the role of Ai in Oshi no Ko episode 7, Frieren’s defeat of Aura in Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End episode 10, and Rudeus discovering Fitz’s true identity in Mushoku Tensei II episode 11 among them – but this was the most emotionally powerful scene of the year by far; just rewatching it to prepare this piece teared me up again. It’s not the only reason that Oshi no Ko had one of the strongest debut episodes ever, or that the theme song which referred to it was one of the biggest anisongs ever, but it played an important role in both.
OP of the Year: “Idol” by Yoasobi, Oshi no Ko
“Idol” by YOASOBI (English version)
There were a wealth of good options here, too. “Hero,” also by YOASOBI, for Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End gradually became a favorite for how perfectly its lyrics described the series’ storyline and underlying themes, while “A Quieted Lineage” by JUNNA (for The Ancient Magus’ Bride s2p2) stood out for its conceptual design, “WORK” by millenium parade X Ringo Sheena (Hell’s Paradise) had the best visual presentation, and “Entertainment” by Mili (Goblin Slayer 2) was the best advertisement for its series and had maybe the best line: “I will win your one-sided game.” However, the full-length version of “Idol” – which has been widely-praised for its multiple viewpoints, skillful key changes, and emotional appeal for those who have seen episode 1 – was the biggest song of the year in Japan, briefly hit #1 on the global charts, and is easily one of the single biggest anisongs ever by most measures. Such a feat has to be acknowledged. It’s also a damn catchy song which, in either version, speaks to the truths of the first episode and has spent more time stuck in my head than any other anisong in 2023.
ED of the Year: “Anytime, Anywhere” by milet, Frieren: Beyond Journey’s End
This one wasn’t even a contest, since “Anytime, Anywhere” blew everything else away from the first time I saw it. The song hits exactly the right note of sentimentality to match the series, but it also matches perfectly with a beautiful animation effort done in the style of complex embroidery patterns. This is a sublime work of art which will make my All-Time-Greats list in this category.
Best Insert Song: “Not Meet Doubt” by Saori Hayami, DanMachi episode 20
Note: I am linking to this version, rather than the official Warner Brothers Japan stream, because this one has translated lyrics
There were also a lot of great insert songs to choose from this year, with seeming every major title having at least one – and that’s without getting into the actual musical shows. However, none of them had the devastating impact that this one managed. It plays during the fall of Astrea Familia before the Juggernaut, and its soulful, aching lament tinged with love (which becomes much more evident when you see the translated lyrics) delivers the emotion of the scene so much more effectively that the more darkly dramatic pieces used elsewhere in the series’ soundtrack could. Fittingly, it is sung by Ryu Lion’s seiyuu.
Oddest Protagonist: Boxxo, Reborn as a Vending Machine, I Wander the Dungeon
This actually isn’t the first anime which has had a sentient vending machine as a protagonist (see also Coffee Samurai), but this isekai series does vastly more with the concept than its predecessor does and, quite surprisingly, makes it work. Though Boxxo can defeat opponents in a mostly-roundabout way, it’s in his ability to alter economies and support his allies by what he provides (and the different types of vending machines he can transform into) where he really shines. He turns the series into a much cleverer work and also manages to bond with lead girl Lammis despite his limited ability to communicate.
Guilty Pleasure: Farming Life in Another World
This award goes to the title that I rewatched most heavily this year despite not being able to acknowledge it as a quantifiable quality title. It’s a relatively simple tale about isekai protagonist Hiraku, who gets reincarnated into a fantasy world and, with the help of a magical tool, decides to create a farm in the midst of what to anyone else would be a hostile forest. Along the way he picks up a diverse array of cohabitants, including demon spiders, inferno hounds, vampires, angels, dwarves, lizard men, beast people, demons, and even a dragon, turning his farm into a village which unwittingly terrifies its neighbors with its potential military might, even though Hiraku is only interested in living a peaceful life. Though it has a few good visual moments, it is hardly a great technical work. Despite that, it is well-capable of winning viewers over with its combination of bucolic charm, plentiful light humor, and the amusing irony of how what the village looks like from the outside utterly contrasts with the inside view. It also wins points for a short arc about one character getting pregnant and some interesting world-building tidbits. Overall, it makes for a light but surprisingly involving view.
Most Bizarre World-Building Detail: The standard unit of measurement in Handyman Saitou in another world
Handyman Saitou was mostly a collection of fantasy comedy shorts about and isekai’d handyman and how he finds more job satisfaction in his new world than his old, and it certainly had its fair share of jokes. Easily the most sputter-worthy one, though, was the revelation that the maderaka (a unit roughly equal to a foot or 30 cm) was based on the length of an early king’s male member.
That’s all for now! I’ll be back on January 3rd for the Winter ’24 Preview Guide coverage.
USA Anime 