Winter 2025 Preview Guide

Final Update: 3:37 p.m. EST 1/12/25

Welcome to my seasonal Guide! (The debut schedule can be found here.)

One series – Solo Leveling s2 – previously debuted in a theatrical release. A write-up on that one can be seen here, so it will not be revisited in this Guide. Season 2 of The Apothecary Diaries is also not covered here since that series is going straight to episode reviews.

Beyond those, I expect to cover every full-episode series that will be debuting this season and many of the sequels/returning series, including Ishura, My Happy Marriage, The 100 Girlfriends Who Really(x5) Love You, and Unnamed Memory. I will not be covering sequels for Blue Exorcist, Dr. Stone, Kinnikuman, Precure, Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun, or UniteUp! Grisaia: Phantom Trigger the Animation is being covered, but see the comments below on that one.

Debuts are listed below in with the newest ones at the top.

NOTE: With the posting of The Red Ranger, this edition of the Preview Guide is now complete except for possible minor error corrections.

The Red Ranger Becomes an Adventurer in Another World

Streams: Crunchyroll on Sundays

Rating: 3.5

This concept – crossing a cheesy combining-robot super sentai series with an isekai series – had to happen at some point, didn’t it? That’s the basic gimmick of this manga adaptation. Togo is Kizuna Red, the leader of a five-member team attempting to defeat the Break-Up King and his forces from separating all of the bonds in the world. Though he succeeds in defeating the King, he finds himself falling into another world instead of falling to the ground in his own. There he becomes an adventurer while looking for a way home and crosses paths with Yihdra, daughter of a disgraced court mage, who is seeking to reestablish her family’s legacy as overseers of her kingdom’s magic. She has very magical girl-like sentiments about magic that Togo can deeply relate to, and he has abilities that she’s perplexed by, so the two wind up forming an adventuring party.

So the whole thing is silly in a high-spirited way, even down to the visual effects that happen when Togo transforms or defeats foes (there are always explosions) and the ridiculous attack names, which are all centered around forming bonds (Marriage Beam Gun, Proposal Pot Shot). Yihdra plays the straight woman in all of this as Togo utterly overwhelms all her common sense, but by the end of the episode she’s also clearly starting to find his unbridled passion and sincerity hard to resist. I love how the series goes whole-hog on its concept and runs with it, and I even don’t mind Yihdra’s blatantly fan servicey get-up (which Togo, curiously, seems utterly unfazed by). This one’s definitely earn at least a couple more episodes from me and may be a keeper.

The 100 Girlfriends Who Really (x5) Love You 2

Streams: Crunchyroll on Sundays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

I am far from being a big fan of this franchise (frankly, I feel it’s way overrated), but the first season did have its moments, and one of those is used to start off the second season. The body-switch is a gimmick with a long history in harem series, but this is one of the most expansive and quickest uses of it that I’ve seen, with all the existing girlfriends being involved. Seeing the same personalities in different bodies – even if only for a few minutes – is fun, and I can see why Rentaro is excited by it short-term but prefers them back in their original bodies long-term: in anime, personality and body type are much more inextricably linked than in most other visual media. But that and the fourth-wall-breaking comments definitely make for a cheeky, high-energy opening to the season.

I was less impressed when the series settles back into its more normal routine, which, of course, involves Rentaro discovering another one of his soulmates and trying to win her over. This time there’s a plausible reason why Rentaro hasn’t encountered her before even though they’re in the same school: because she’s from the middle school wing. All of the girls feel some kind of personality/body type niche, and Kurume is both the Angry Girl and the Hungry Girl, with an out-of-control ability to make food associations on just about anything, get obsessed with that food, and angry at herself for how that tends to create a largely-self-imposed isolation from others. She also represents the younger love interest so common in these series; whether she’s truly underage or not is a matter of personal taste, but since she and Rentaro are both teens and only one grade apart, I don’t see that as a big deal. Looks like she’s going to need some work to integrate in with the rest of the girls, but that’s fine; this series would be unwatchable if things went too smoothly.

I still have some misgivings about the overall premise behind the series, but at least it’s watchable.

Babanba Banban Vampire

Streams: Netflix on Saturdays

Rating: 1.5 (of 5)

In this adaptation of a BL manga, Ranmaru is a 450-year-old vampire with a manly physique but a feminine air about him. His preferred taste is 18-year-old virgin boys, so he’s been working in a bath house for a decade partly to repay the kindness of the owner’s son an partly to watch over the now-15-year-old boy as his future prey. The problem is that Rihito, the son, has bumped into a girl on his first day of school and fallen instantly in love. Ranmaru is not about to let what he desires most get corrupted early.

In a purely technical sense, this debut episode is better than the rating I’m giving it, but this is such a blatant case of grooming that the series almost seems to be trying to make a joke of it, and frankly, that made me uncomfortable. Ranmaru is even shown getting obvious erections thinking about it. The first episode packs in as much female-oriented fan service as the raciest male-oriented romcoms, too, and I’m not sure what to make of the surprise revelation of who one of Ranmaru’s first lovers was. I am so not the audience for this one, so my rating should probably be taken with a grain of salt, but I can’t see this holding much appeal if you’re not already into BL.

Sakamoto Days

Streams: Neftlix on Saturdays

Rating: 4 (of 5)

In this manga adaptation, Taro Sakamoto was the most elite of assassins until love struck him, at which point he retired, started a family, and became the owner/operator of a convenience store. Five years later, former coworker (and big admirer) Shin tracks him down and tries to convince Sakamoto to come back, but the latter refuses. Shin’s under orders to kill Sakamoto if he can’t recruit him, which he reluctantly tries to do, but he quickly learns that even though Sakamoto has gotten fat, not even a mind-reading assassin is still a match for him. In the end, Shin winds up working for Sakamoto as a clerk at his store.

This was one of the most-anticipated new series of the season, and the first episode lives up to the hype. Shin’s actually the viewpoint character, since Sakamoto almost never speaks out loud, but that just allows audiences to appreciate more how slick Sakamoto is, especially at using all sorts of ordinary objects to thwart would-be attackers. Sharp action sequences are frequent highlights, but this is a good-looking series in general, with one exception that really bugged me: Shin’s head seems disproportionately small for his body. This one looks like it has real promise as a rousing action/comedy.

I Left My A-Rank Party

Streams: Crunchyroll on Fridays

Rating: 3.5 (of 5)

In this light novel adaptation, Yuke Feldio is a B-rank Red Mage/Alchemist, which basically means he’s the dedicated buffer and supporter for his elite and famous A-rank party. But after five years with the party, he feels he is not being respected enough to be paid a fair share, so he decides to leave the group, and they’re all perfectly fine with shooing him out the door since none of them had seen him as an equal anyway. While applying for a new party, Yuke encounters a trio of former students who are now a fledgling D-rank party, and they invite him to join them. Yuke can see that they learned well from him, and they quickly come to appreciate how useful he can be, so they become the new up-and-coming party Clover.

Given the title, how stereotypical the three girls look and act, and the basic premise of the series, I wasn’t expecting much from this one. However, director Katsumi Ono showed with Skeleton Knight in Another World that he knows how to deliver fun, high-spirited fantasy series, and that definitely shows here, turning this into one of the season’s more pleasant surprises for me. Doubtless this will be another scenario where the high-level party starts floundering without its key support element (as much as I’d like to criticize this stereotypical short-sightedness, I have personally experienced tabletop RPG groups with the same attitude as Thunder Pike IRL), but seeing how well Yuke works with the girls – and how much happier he seems with them – helps overcome some of the more standard aspects, and seeing that the girls learned their lessons well is another plus. The world also adds the mostly-novel twists of adventuring parties being able to live-stream their adventures. (Slime has done this previously, but I think that’s the only other series where I’ve seen that.) I also loved that when Yuke gets hugged by the armored warrior girl, his reaction was about getting crushed by the hug, rather than her breasts pushing against him. Technical and artistic merits are decent, too. This will make my seasonal viewing list, so don’t underestimate it.

Übel Blatt

Streams: Amazon Prime on Fridays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

This one is based on a manga which ran from 2004 through 2019. That starting date is important, because the series’ first episode definitely feels like it comes from an earlier fantasy era, when dark, bloody titles like Berserk and Claymore were more en vogue. This is strongly implied to be one big revenge tale, where a survivor of a gruesome betrayal by a group that would become known as the Seven Heroes has returned, 20 years later, to seek vengeance on those heroes. Only now he looks decidedly more elfin than he did when he was supposedly slain; the first episode reveals nothing about how that came to pass, but presumably it will be explained later on.

This episode involves the protagonist, Koinzell, seeking to get smuggled onto a ship to the Other Side (where the Seven Heroes are) at a port for flying ships controlled by warrior monks. There he meets a trio of characters suggested by the ED to become regulars: an elf girl, a human man also looking to be smuggled, and a human woman who’s organizing the smuggling and seems to be a talented warrior herself. Naturally, things don’t go smoothly, much blood gets spilled (mostly by Koinzell), and Koinzell seemingly dies but gets better.

There’s a clear efforts here to make this a brooding, violent tale about a corrupt world, but the first episode struggles some to execute that smoothly. It doesn’t help that action scenes take big shortcuts, and the style of dress used for most of the female characters is. . . interesting. Most crucial scenes are either a bit over the top or not enough, but at least the world-building looks interesting visually. I’m leery about whether or not this one call pull off what it’s aiming to do, so I’m giving it a neutral grade for now.

Farmagia

Streams: Crunchyroll on Fridays

Rating: 1.5 (of 5)

This one is the anime version of a recently-released RPG/farming sim game for Switch, PS%, and Stream, and the way the first episode plays out suggests that it’s going to follow the story of the game pretty closely. I’m pretty sure it’s entirely intended for people already familiar with the game, as it spends no time whatsoever explaining its setting or world structure. What is evident from this episode is that the world consists of mini-continents that look like they sprout from the corpses of immense creatures and that farmers called Farmagia raise crops that turn into “buddy monsters,” some of which perform tasks for the Farmagia and others of which serve various utility purposes in towns, including lighting fixtures. Clearly a lot of creative effort went into the visual design elements, and that’s the one thing that I will give the episode credit for because otherwise the debut episode is a mess.

The single biggest problem is main protagonist Ten, who may be the most obnoxious lead character to come along in some time. He’s an utter idiot who shouts everything he says. There’s also a girl who eats things to see if they’re poisonous or not; I think that’s supposed to be funny, but it’s not. The others of the main quintet are as bad but aren’t memorable, either. Events proceed at a frenetic pace, including minimal action scenes and pathetic attempts at humor at inappropriate times. And that’s without figuring in some not-good CG, too. Honestly, I found the whole thing unwatchable. More power to you if you can appreciate this one.

I May Be a Guild Receptionist

Streams: Crunchyroll

Rating: 4 (of 5)

Adventurers Guild receptionist girls have become a staple in fantasy anime over the last decade, but they have always been nameless bit characters or, at best, significant supporting characters. This new light novel adaptation is, to my knowledge, the first where a guild receptionist is both a central and titular character, and that alone makes this title stick out. The more surprising big plus is that this artistic and animation effort from CloverWorks also looks surprisingly good, easily visually placing this among the cream of the crop of fantasy series so far this season.

The concept is gimmicky, but fun: Alina Clover dreams of having stable, safe employment where she can clock out on schedule and enjoy her downtime, so she signed up to be an adventurer’s guild receptionist (in a guild office which looks remarkably high-tech for a fantasy setting, such as having quests displayed on holographic billboards). The problem is that adventurers struggling with a dungeons are causing her overtime, and she can’t tolerate that, so she decides to take matters into her own hands and deal with a troublesome dungeon boss herself. The follow-up problem is that, despite her efforts to conceal her identity, the leader of a strong party recognized her and now wants to recruit her, but she’ll have none of that.

A lot is unexplained at this point, such as how Alina is so out-of-proportion strong or where she’s getting that massive hammer from. But those are questions which can be sorted out with time. Alina is an appreciable lead and the first episode is paced well, uses a number of interesting selections on shot framing, and even establishes a possible future dynamic between Alina and the leader of the Silver Swords. It’s even got an entertaining musical score, too. It’s possible I’m overrating this one a bit, but it feels like a winner so far.

Welcome to Japan, Ms. Elf!

Streams: Crunchyroll on Fridays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

Since he was a child, 25-year-old Kazuhiko has found himself wandering a fantasy land while dreaming, so his favorite recreational activity as an adult is sleeping. If he dies in that fantasy world, he just wakes up back in his room. Marie, an elf sorcerer he’s well-acquainted with in that other world, happens to be with him when one of those deaths occurs, and to both Kazuhiko’ and Marie’s shock, she’s naked in his bed in Japan when he wakes up the next morning. (The situation strongly suggested that she would have died, too.) Marie quickly shows a fascination with this new world, so Kazuhiko takes the day off to get her some clothes and show her around.

A lot of the mechanics of what’s going on here need to be sorted out, such as whether Marie can also go back to that world when sleeping, but the OP/ED and series concept suggest that she’s going to be in modern Japan for the long term. But a whole series about adjusting to life in modern Japan – with a tinge of potential romance and some fan service thrown in for good measure – doesn’t at all sound like a bad concept, and this episode does earn points for considering practical issues like language barriers. (Marie can understand Kazuhiko, but not Japanese in general.) Character designs and animation are far from the most refined (which is the main reason I’m not rating this higher), but the pacing is good and both main characters seem likable so far. This isn’t going to be a flashy or high-concept series, but I can see it offering steady entertainment, and so think it’s likely to make my seasonal viewing list.

Anyway, I’m Falling in Love with You

Streams: Crunchyroll on Wednesdays

Rating: 3

Mizuha’s 27th birthday (in 2030) isn’t going well, which causes her to reflect back to the time of her 17th birthday. At that time, she still hung out with the gang of four neighborhood boys she grew up with, with nary a hint of romance complicating things among them – at least on her end, anyway, since she saw herself as a big sister to all of them. But one of those boys didn’t feel the same, and him taking steps to make that clear on her 17th birthday threatens to upset the long-time dynamic among the quintet.

In many respects this is a fairly standard “things get complicated among friends when romance comes into the picture” scenario, but with a couple of non-standard twists. One is that all four of the guys in question are tall, incredibly hot bishonen (must be something in the water in Mizuha’s childhood neighborhood!), which makes it hard to not look at this as a reverse-harem scenario, especially since at least one or two of the other boys are implied to have beyond-friends feelings, too. The other is the timing. The teenage part takes place in 2020, and while the series dodges mentioning it by name, the beginning of COVID is having a distinct impact on the course of events. That is, to my knowledge, a first for anime, and I’m rather curious to see if it will continue to be integrated into the story going forward. Otherwise this feels like a fairly standard teen romantic drama with some mild touches of humor; decent, but nothing special on both artistic and writing fronts.

Aquarion: Myth of Emotions

Streams: Crunchyroll on Thursdays

Rating: 2 (of 5)

This is technically a sequel to Aquarion Evol, and thus the fourth title in the Aquarion franchise, though I’m not sure that any previous familiarity with the franchise is necessary here since this seems to be an entirely different cast. Very basically, the concept is more or less the same: a quartet of youths who may be reincarnations from thousands of years earlier (though only one of them seems to be aware of that) are assembled in a secret school program to train to fight mythical creatures. That involves piloting Vector Machines to face the threat. There’s supposed to be a fourth Vector Machine, but those in charge initially seem unaware that the trio of Vector Machines have to combine to make Aquarion. There’s also a girl who supposed died (and even had a funeral) but still keeps showing up and is the one who remembers the most about the reincarnation stuff.

There’s a strong suggestion that a lot of what we’re seeing as reality here isn’t real, and the visuals do lean heavily into CG effects. But that doesn’t matter so much as the very curious visual style, which feels like it’s aimed at a much younger audience than any previous franchise installment. I don’t care for it, especially in the very angular character designs (and especially in characters’ eyes), and it’s plenty enough to discourage me – and probably a lot of others – from watching more. Maybe there’s an interesting storyline and characters here, but not enough of that shows to warrant putting up with those visuals.

From Bureaucrat to Villainess: Dad’s Been Reincarnated!

Streams: HIDIVE on Thursdays

Rating: 3.5 (of 5)

Kenzaburo, a 52-year-old bureaucrat, is only vaguely familiar with isekai reincarnation scenarios and otome games, in the latter case mainly because he’s seen one of his daughters play one. Thus he finds it odd that he’d be chosen to be reincarnated into that same otome game after getting hit by Truck-kun, and as the ringlet-endowed 15-year-old villainess-to-be, too! Though he doesn’t really know the ins and outs of otome games, he decides to play along as best he can, using his life experiences to guide himself (or rather herself, since he’s now Grace Auvergne, daughter of a duke) through various counters. The problem for him is that he can’t help sliding into Dad Mode at times, and thus unwittingly starts scoring points with the commoner girl who’s supposed to be the game’s heroine.

The grade I’m giving this one is a compromise, as this brilliant twist on the standard villainess set-up is getting bogged down so badly by some of the season’s weakest visuals that I can’t justify rating it as high as I want to. The writing and storytelling gimmickry here are enormous fun, especially the main character slipping into Dad Mode at times and delighting in how some things that were being cumbersome for him in his original life (like reading small print) were now so much easier for him, although the implication that he’s earning romance flags with the heroine is an amusing bit, too. I’ll fully admit that this series may be more squarely aimed at me than most in this genre, since I am close to the same age and can relate to some of Kenzaburo’s original-life issues, but it’s such a delight in every sense other than artistry that it’s certain to make my view list for the season. It even has one the season’s best EDs – or would have if, again, it wasn’t saddled with its animation limitations.

Even Given the Worthless “Appraiser” Class, I’m Actually the Strongest

Streams: Crunchyroll on Thursdays

Rating: 2.5 (of 5)

Disrespecting and maltreating supporters in a fantasy RPG-influenced setting is hardly just an anime thing; references to (and humor about) this is probably nearly as old as fantasy TTRPGs are. Sadly, adventurers being complete dicks to supporters – even to the point of treating them as disposable – is entirely believable, since in any setting, even run-of-the-mill adventurers are still elites in skill and ability. The opening episode of this light novel adaptation dwells on this to a depressing degree, even establishing that being relegated to lower-class status is something set at birth. Ein is the unfortunate soul in this case, as the hereditary Appraiser class boasts no combat abilities. Since he can’t continue a family business, he’s relegated to being a “trash-picker” for an adventuring duo, so of course he’s abandoned to bait away dangerous monsters while the other two escape. That’s only the beginning of his deadly troubles, though a kind soul apparently connected to an underground World Tree (the hidden source of mana in this setting) does seem intent on helping him.

The OP and ED both show Ein doing awesome things, but this first episode gives no indication about how that’s going to come to pass. But he’s also just started to meet the bevy of beauties who, according to the OP and ED, will eventually gather around him. First, though, he has to endure almost getting eaten and having fingers and an ear temporarily severed; this is actually a pretty graphic first episode. It’s not quite to the edgelord extreme of an Arifureta or Failure Frame, and it certainly looks better, and does a better job of setting the mood, than either of those (although that isn’t saying much). The OP and ED make the series look like it will eventually become the most generic of power fantasy series, so I’m currently regarding this one with a wary eye, but I’ll reserve harsher judgment until I see more.

The Daily Life of a Middle-Aged Online Shopper in Another World

Streams: Crunchyroll on Thursdays

Rating: 2 (of 5)

I’ll give this light novel adaptation credit for one thing: it starts with will likely be the cheekiest opening minute of any series this season. Rather than go into detail about how 38-year-old Kenichi overworked himself to health problems, moved to the country, and from there gets transported to another world and discovers that he can call up an Item Box and screen for an online shopping site, the series just summarizes that in a montage of images set to the opening theme from 2001: A Space Odyssey, with his display screen taking the place of the monolith and it ending with “2037: Another world odyssey.”

Sadly, that’s the most creative this debut episode ever gets, with the rest playing out as a very standard take on the growing subgenre of isekai stories centered around taking goods from modern Japan and selling them in the new world. There are at least tidbits which could lead to something more: Kenichi does get at least some credit for briefly wondering how things he’s ordering end up there, by the end of the episode he’s strongly implied to be in a physical relationship with a barmaid he unwittingly charms, and he’ll have to watch out for syndicates as he sells his goods, but these are only little sparks. The OP shown at the end of the episode strongly suggests that he’ll eventually form an adventuring party, but really, nothing on either writing, characterization, or artistic fronts feels compelling here. It’s hardly the worst debut of this season, but I’m expecting little from it.

Ishura s2

Streams: Hulu on Wednesdays

Rating: 3.5 (of 5)

One of the best aspects of the first season of Ishura was the diverse array of Shura it introduced to us. Though the plot did advance in the later stages of the first season, this season returns to the form of the first season’s early episodes by introducing two (possibly three?) new Shura and bringing back one familiar one. One of the newcomers is Mele the Horizon’s Roar, a giant archer who can divert raging floodwaters with his shots or successfully face down the Demon King’s Army but gentle enough to grant the request of a dying human child. He will be participating in the grand hero tournament announced in the first season. The second is the (former?) spy Kuuro the Cautious, whose gift is clairvoyance and an uncanny ability to snipe foes in a crowd with a hand crossbow. He’s involved with Aureatia but seems to be on a different trajectory. There’s also a suggestion that a storm worshiped as a god by desert tribesman might be one, too, but that’s more hazy.

In other words, this season is at least starting out as “more of the same,” including on visual and graphic content fronts. That’s fine for now, as both of the characters featured here are interesting additions, but the real test will be when the plot starts to thicken later this season. For now, though, if you at least tolerated the first season then this one shouldn’t change your mind.

Honey Lemon Soda

Streams: Crunchyroll on Wednesdays

Rating: 4 (of 5)

In this manga adaptation, Uka was bullied in middle school and there earned the nickname “Stony” because of her tendency to freeze up in social situations. Though academically capable of going to a better high school, she winds up going to a lesser one in part because of Kai, a yellow-haired boy with a penchant for lemon soda who made quite an impression on her during a brief street encounter while she was trying to make up her mind. Once in high school, she still struggles to change even before discovering that her former bullies are also attending the school, but thanks in part to a not-so-gentle push from Kai, she is able to stand up and start to change her circumstances.

Boy, I did not expect this one to hit me as hard emotionally as it did. Structurally speaking, it’s a fairly standard story about a girl who has been bullied who is slow to adjust to not being bullied and thus needs a push to make a change. Enter the popular stand-out who can come across as cold and a bit harsh, but he’s not completely uncaring and he does pay more attention than he lets on, and one timely display of the latter near the end of the episode is what got to me. On the artistic front, the way the oversized eyes are drawn in close-ups is what sticks out the most, and not necessarily in a good way, but the overall aesthetic is passable. I have concerns about whether this series can maintain the high impact level it introduces in the first episode, but it at least makes a good first impression.

Magic Maker: How to Make Magic in Another World

Streams: Crunchyroll on Wednesdays

Rating: 4 (of 5)

The flood of isekai titles each season may produce a lot of samey dreck, but the high volume also assures that we will at least occasionally see sometime entirely different. This light novel adaptation is one such title. Its first big twist is that the first episode doesn’t actually focus on the story’s protagonist; all but the last scene come from the viewpoint of Marie, a tomboyish daughter of a country noble. From her observations, we can tell that Shion, the younger brother she adores and looks out for, was probably an isekai reincarnation from birth, though that fact isn’t absolutely confirmed until the viewpoint shifts to Shion in the episode’s last scene. That makes for an interestingly different perspective.

The second big twist is that this world may have monsters and fairies (although the latter are quite rare), but it either doesn’t even have the concept of magic or else it is such esoteric knowledge that its existence is not commonly-known. Hence Shion, rather than tapping into an established magical tradition, has to build magic from the ground up from the basis of a magic-like effect derived from the courtship of fish. This is such a fascinatingly different approach that I greatly look forward to seeing where the series goes with it. A firm establishment of the core cast, including not everyone apparently being able to see the magic-like effect, is another plus, and while the series doesn’t look spectacular, it’s not bad, either. This one’s a definite keeper.

Flower and Asura

Streams: HIDIVE on Tuesdays

Rating: 3.5 (of 5)

Fledgling high schooler Hana has always loved dramatic recitations, and has such a talent for it herself that Mizuki, the president of her new school’s Broadcasting Club, actively seeks to recruit her. But Hana is reluctant to ask for anything, and the ferry service to the small island where she lives (she’s the only teenager) would make her participation difficult. But Mizuki isn’t about to let such a promising candidate go so easily, and Mizuki does seem interested even if she doesn’t want to admit it.

This adaptation is based on a manga written by the creator of Sound! Euphonium, and that definitely explains the feel of the first episode. Plot-wise, it’s a fairly typical “draw the newbie into a club of eccentrics” scenario, Hana is fairly typical as the reluctant but talented newcomer, and Mizuki is a standard go-getter of a senpai, but the interesting setting (Hana must take a boat to school!) and the dramatic visual presentations of the recitations offer some promise, as does some ambitious use of symbolism. I can’t see me getting involved in this one enough to follow it, but it should appeal to the same kind of audience who got wrapped up in Sound! Euphonium.

Unnamed Memory p2 (ep 13)

Streams: Crunchyroll on Tuesdays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

Crunchyroll is marking this as a continuation rather than a separate season, and so is number the return episode 13. However you interpret it, I strongly recommend rewatching episode 12 before continuing with this one, as having the events of episode 12 fresh in mind is crucial for understanding what’s going on here.

Last season ended with a stunning turn of events, one which radically rewrote the backstory of one co-protagonist and effectively ended the existence of the other (or at least the version viewers had been following to that point) – for in this causality, changes to the past eradicate the future rather than creating a branch in reality. Because of that, Tinasha is no longer technically a witch (even though she’s as powerful as one) and so has to put herself into magical sleep so she can see future Oscar in his proper time. And he does, indeed, show up to a Tuldarr that was never destroyed, seeking a cure to his blessing/curse from them rather than from a legendary witch. She again goes to Farsas for half a year to research how to break the curse, but this isn’t the Oscar who came back in time to save her, and she has difficulty reconciling that. Also, the current leader of Tuldarr is intent on having her marry her nation’s prince in order to rejuvenate the fading magical power of their royal bloodline, leaving Tinasha conflicted in priorities.

The meat of an interesting storyline is here, as is the dynamic of the central couple having to re-establish their romance (since they’re both technically different people than the last time). However, like with the first half of the series, signs of issues in the storytelling are already starting to creep into the picture. How much the ruler of Tuldarr actually knows about the barrier-protected area where Tinasha sleeps, and who or what may be within, seems inconsistent, and his insistence on marrying her to his son seems improbably ballsy given the kind of prestige she should have within Tuldarr. The story’s gotten in trouble for cutting corners before, and I’m worried that’s happening again here. Still, I’ve always liked scenarios like these – where the characters have to replay history but with different circumstances – so I’m giving this series the benefit of the doubt for now.

I Have a Crush at Work

Streams: Nowhere legal on Mondays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

This adaptation of a seinen manga is essentially the reverse situation of 365 Days to a Wedding, the series that it will inevitably be constantly compared to (for better or worse). Instead of pretending to be engaged, coworkers Masagu and Yui are pretending to not be involved at all once they clandestinely agree to start dating. Like 365‘s Takuya and Rika, that means jumping through all kinds of hoops to keep up the appearances and deflect suspicion from their actual relationship, but in this case it’s because both are keen to avoid getting caught up in workplace gossip. Expected hijinks ensue.

With both visuals and animation support being rather bland, this series is largely going to be carried by the comedy inherent in their efforts to avoid looking lovey-dovey around people at work. Masagu and Yui do at least have a certain amount of chemistry together by the end of the episode, enough so to be convincing that they actually are a couple, though their reactions to various relationship hurdles (like addressing each other by first names) seems rather juvenile for individuals who are supposed to be 28. At least they are strongly implied to have sex towards the end of the episode, which, frankly, may be the series’ saving grace and gives me a little hope for this one. Can’t see following it unless it gets picked up by a proper licensor, though.

My Happy Marriage 2

Streams: Netflix on Mondays

Rating: 4.5 (of 5)

Despite heavy competition, the first season of My Happy Marriage was among the best-looking series of 2023, and that has certainly not changed with its continuation into its second season. (An OVA episode also available on Netflix technically takes place between the seasons, but it is not necessary viewing before starting this season.) Its gorgeous backgrounds and character designs and elegant animation effort still continue to dazzle and the usually-gentle and subdued soundtrack continues to offer just the right note of support. The real question, then, is whether the story can go anywhere compelling after the major resolutions at the end of season 1. If the first episode is any indication, that won’t anything to be concerned about.

Essentially, Miyo is playing “let’s meet the future in-laws,” as the elder Kudo comes to Tokyo to ask Kiyoka to come investigate something out near his country estate – something that Prince Takaihito also wants to see happen, curiously, including Miyo coming along. Though the sightseeing is wonderful for her, the real problem is Kiyoka’s mother, who is so rude and denigrating towards Miyo that she almost seems to be picking a fight. While Kiyoka won’t have anything to do with her unpleasantness, Miyo is determined to get on at least civil terms with her. But that’s not the only conflict powering the story, especially with Takaihito proclaiming that a “catastrophe” is coming, demons seeming to creep around on the fringes of civilization, and Miyo getting the sense that someone was watching her in Tokyo.

In other words, this is practically an ideal episode to start off the season with and easily one of the two strongest debuts so far this season. If you liked season 1, there’s no reason you shouldn’t be satisfied with the start of this one, too.

I’m a Noble on the Brink of Ruin, So I Might as Well Try Mastering Magic

Streams: Crunchyroll on Mondays

Rating: 1 (of 5)

If someone were deliberately trying to make the blandest and most juvenile isekai power fantasy imaginable, it would look something like this light novel adaptation. Nothing about it isn’t generic: the protagonist passed out while drinking in modern-day Japan and finds himself in the body of 12-yar-old Liam Hamilton, the fifth son of a noble, in a fantasy world. The family’s due to lose its noble title unless it distinguishes itself (the setting’s one interesting world-building feature is that noble titles only last for three generations), so Liam’s already making plans of his own. That plan involves mastering magic, which he just happens to be godly talented at, and he just happens to attract the attention of an eccentric master who gives him key pointers and gifts. When he aims to become Hunter (read: adventurer), he quickly picks up a sexy blonde warrior-type and a more mature brunette caster-type as regular party members and later familiars, which empowers them at the risk of being subject to his whims, but of course he would never abuse that, and now a princess is getting involved, too!

Yeah, it’s going all those places with barely an ounce of deeper thought about anything, including what happened to the original Liam, who doesn’t appear to have been dying or anything. Add on top of that some of the lamest-looking monsters, essentially no fight animation, and the weakest visual effort you’ll probably see all season (especially for any characters beyond the featured ones) and you have a series which shows little hope of getting any better. The source novel, which got a one-star review on ANN, is from the same novelist who wrote My Unique Skill Makes Me OP even at Level 1 (which was one of the most lackluster series of 2023), so expectations here are really low.

Medaka Kuriowa is Impervious to My Charms

Streams: Crunchyroll on Mondays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

Between her looks and personal charm (and, as she gets older, killer figure) Mona has been a social queen bee literally since birth. Once she realizes that, she prides herself in it, to the point that, by the time she’s 17, she can effortlessly charm anyone. Because of that, she’s thrown for a loop when new transfer student Medaka not only pointedly ignores her but also seems to actively resist even her sexier efforts. As she frets over whether or not she might be getting charmed by him instead, she’s completely unaware that Medaka is hardly unaffected by her but is determined to stay away from women in pursuit of his religious path.

We’ve seen gimmicks like the one presented by this manga adaptation before, and they always hinge on how likable both characters are and whether the chemistry between them is believable. On those points, the first episode is a mixed bag. Mona is clearly a narcissist and an egotist, but she’s not a malicious one; she seems to just be an attention hound rather than doing things like using her charm to manipulate people, and there is a certain adorability to how she tries to use sex appeal. (She only uses it as a last resort, and is mindful of pushing too far with it.) Thanks to a delicate balancing act, she comes across as at least tolerable. Medaka, meanwhile, is fairly believable as a young man working hard to fight off his urges. Too soon to tell if the chemistry is happening, but perhaps until the series can sustain itself with support for a surprising concentration on fan services. (Nothing too racy, but there are underwear shots, suggestive camera angles, and very short skirts.) I’m giving this one a lower mark primarily because the first episode wasn’t as funny as I felt it should have been, but I will probably give this one another episode or two to see how other cast members featured in the OP and ED fit into the developing dynamic.

Promise of Wizard

Streams: Crunchyroll on Mondays

Rating: 1 (of 5)

Normally I reserve a rating this low for something truly awful, but in this case the rating is a reflection of how utterly dull and lifeless its first episode is. The series adapts a mobile game of the same name where the player is a Great Sage summoned from modern Japan into a fantasy world where Wizards (who are, of course, all dashing bishonen) are struggling to fend off the Great Calamity (i.e., their moon), which descends once a year to wreak havoc. Normally it isn’t a problem, but for some reason it’s much tougher to deal with this time, hence the need for the Great Sage to lead and support them.

In other words, it’s pretty standard older-school isekai set-up, with the only minor twist this time being that one of the world’s governments seeks to control the Great Sage so that they can, by extension, control the Wizards, and the Wizards are having none of that. It’s clearly also aiming for a literary flair, with characters names including Cock Robin and Shylock. However, the first episode is completely lacking in energy and style. One of the Wizards’ companions is apparently gravely injured and they’re hoping the Great Sage can do something about it, but there’s zero sense of urgency about that or the soldiers who are trying to capture them. None of the wizards shown so far have any compelling spark of appeal, and viewpoint character Akira (the young woman in the center above) is as drab in both appearance and personality as you’d expect a dedicated viewer insert character to be. A weak animation effort, which shows little more liveliness than anything else, is the final blow. This one was a chore to sit through, so I can’t recommend it for any audience.

ZENSHU

Streams: Crunchyroll on Sundays

Rating: 4.5 (of 5)

This was one of the season’s most highly-anticipated new series based largely on the strength of it being an original production from studio MAPPA and the director of two of the funniest series of the past 11 years: Monthly Girls Nozaki-kun and Sleepy Princess in Demon King Castle. The anticipation was warranted, as based on the first episode, it’s absolutely a keeper. I can easily see this being one of the biggest new titles of the season.

The premise is a variation on the standard “transported into a story world” isekai, only this time, instead of being a lonely otaku, the interdimensional traveler is Natsuko Hirose, a young “genius” animator who became a sensation with her directorial debut but is now struggling mightily with her follow-up project. Ironically, her isekai transport is triggered by the same thing which just did in the director of one of her favorite anime movies: food poisoning. She awakens to find herself in the world of that depressing movie and watching as key events play out just like they did in the movie. While struggling with accepting the reality of the situation, she discovers her unique magic – the ability to literally bring what she animates to life – to prevent one of the movie’s defining tragedies.

The description above may not sound like anything special, but execution matters here, and this debut positively shines in its details and animation. Natsuko’s creation of a monsters straight from storyboards (it even has animation notes surrounding it as it moves!) is the greatest visual spectacle, but the crisp, vibrant animation shines in other scenes, too, as do the designs for both Natsuko and movie hero Luke, while other characters seem to deliberately retain more cartoonish looks. Credit also goes to strong musical support and all the neat little background details, such as the crumbling walls of Last City. One issue I could see here is that the subtitles and the English simuldub refer to mini-unicorn Unio by different pronouns, but otherwise this is the strongest debut so far this season.

I Want to Escape from Princess Lessons

Streams: Crunchyroll on Sundays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

In this light novel adaptation, Leticia, the daughter of a duke, is a rambunctious and free-spirited girl who feels quite constrained when she’s chosen to be betrothed to Crown Prince Clarke, as it means constant training and expectations that she will behave as a proper lady. When, at age 17, the prince shows up to a ball with a new woman on his arm, she’s actually delighted with the assumption that this means the engagement is broken off and quickly plans to move to a family home out in the country, much to the consternation of her older brother. But the OP and ED strongly suggest that this move will not free her from entanglements with Prince Clarke, whose heart may not have turned as far away from Leticia as she thinks.

This is one series which might have benefited from a double-episode debut, as it feels like the crux of the main story’s gimmick hasn’t been fully revealed by the end of the episode. Most of this first episode involves Leticia learning to endure, stone-faced, through the rigorous training to be a future queen, which does successfully cast her as a sympathetic character. Because of that, the sudden tonal transition when Leticia finally believes that she’s been released from all of that is all the sharper. It reveals that Leticia may have been holding in her exuberant spirit to get by, but it’s still there and quite capable of making a spectacle of herself. The OP strongly suggests that Prince Clarke is going to continue to pursue her and attempt to win her over, though, and the real series may be about her continually attempting to dodge his efforts. Frankly, that’s a less appealing long-run prospect, but at least this first episode is executed well and looks pretty good. I’m on the fence about following this one.

Medalist

Streams: Hulu on Saturdays

Rating: 4 (of 5)

In this manga adaptation, 26-year-old Tsukasa was part of a competitive ice dancing team, but is now looking for a skating job to get by between ice skating shows. He’s less than enthusiastic about taking up his former partner’s offer to be an assistant skating coach, but that changes due to encounters with a timid 5th grader named Inori. She desperately wants to skate, but her mother doesn’t want her to because her older daughter was a dedicated skater whose career was cut short by injury and Inori’s on the verge of being too old to start. But Tsukasa finds common ground with Inori on that point, and Inori shows she clearly has the talent. They just may wind up inspiring each other.

As much as the first episode sometimes descends into silly antics, there isn’t another series which has debuted so far this season which even comes close to matching the emotional pull this one offers. There’s no hint of romance on the horizon (or at least, hopefully there’s not?), but Inori and Tsukasa nonetheless need each other, so I can see this becoming a heartwarming coach/student relationship. A skating routine shown at the beginning of the episode looks pretty sharp, too. Seriously doubt I’ll follow this, and it’s not going to be a titan like Yuri on Ice was, but I can easily see this one finding an audience.

Okitsura

Streams: Crunchyroll on Saturdays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

In this manga adaptation, Teruaki is a recent transfer from Tokyo to a high school in Okinawa. Though he seems to be fitting in well, he’s woefully deficient on knowledge of both local customs and Uchinaaguchi, the local language, which is mostly used by older Okinawan natives. The latter is a particular problem because the girl he quickly becomes sweet on, the energetic Hina, speaks mostly in Uchinaaguchi, so he doesn’t understand most of what she’s saying. Thankfully, fellow student Kana translates for him, but unfortunately for Kana, Teruaki is oblivious to the fact that she’s doing it because she’s sweet on him and using it as an excuse to be around him.

Whether or not an actual love triangle is forming here is unclear at this point, as Hina is always viewed by others, and so we don’t know how she feels (or, for that matter, if she’s even mature enough to be interested in romance). But that’s a sidelight in this first episode. The story instead focuses much more on the lightly comical portrayals of the language and cultural barriers Teruaki is faced with, as well as stuffing in all kinds of cultural tidbits on Okinawa. On those fronts, the first episode works pretty well; in fact, all the landmarks featured in the ED are starting to get me interested in visiting Okinawa at some point. Other recent series (Laid-Back Camp, Hokkaido Girls are Super-Adorable!) have shown that these travelogue-flavored series can work with sufficient supporting gimmicks, but I’m currently doubtful that the approach used here will keep my interest.

I’m Living With a Otaku NEET Kunoichi?!

Streams: HIDIVE on Saturdays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

In this manga adaptation, Tsukasa is a perfectly ordinary unmarried salaryman. . . or so he thinks. Unbeknownst to him, his “warrior blood” has started to awaken, and that’s attracting the attention of supernatural monsters. One night a sexy pink-haired ninja swoops in to rescue him from one such monster. Shizuri promises to become Tsukasa’s personal protector from other monster attacks if he’ll let her stay at his place and play video games all day when not performing ninja tasks. (The implication is that she left her ninja village and doesn’t have a place to stay in the city.) Tsukasa, who’s always been a loner, finds this more agreeable than Shizuri had expected, hence setting the stage for future romantic hijinks. But Shizuri also has a “crazy psycho lesbian” stalker from her village – one who’s also a masochist – to deal with, and at least one other female ninja seems to be waiting her turn.

The most negative thing I can say about this debut is that it might have worked better in half-episode format. (Weirdly, the OP plays twice within the episode, so maybe these are two half-episodes mashed together?) The set-up is gimmicky enough that it almost feels like something else may be going on here, as Shizuri is very specifically and deliberately trying to be a NEET rather than just naturally lazing into it. Regardless of that, this is a surprisingly fun debut, with Shizuri being a delight to watch as Tsukasa plays the passive straight man. It looks surprisingly good for what it is, too, and its quirky use of musical score complements the overall light-hearted tone. It’s also surprisingly mild on the fan service front; camera angles definitely tend to linger on busts and rears, but the only scene showing skin (Shizuri’s in a neck-to-toe body suit almost the whole time) is one brief bath scene, and that’s hardly a sexualized scene. I expect this one to become even more lively as additional cast members shown in the OP start popping up, so I’m cautiously optimistic about it at this point.

Sorairo Utility

Streams: HIDIVE on Fridays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

This one is a series-length retelling of on one-shot animation from late 2021 about a high school girl Minami, who finds herself looking for a new hobby when the mobile game she’s poured countless hours into declares that it’s soon shutting down. At the prompting of a friend, she tries out various sports and school clubs, but none of them seem to fit for her. A chance encounter with an elderly man having back troubles leads her to a golf driving range, where she becomes entranced with an older high school girl taking swings. That girl convinces her to try it for herself, and after a few miscues, she may well have found the fit she was looking for.

If Birdie Wing was the sensationalistic version of “girls do golf,” this one is its down-to-earth cousin. The first episode is a by-the-number execution of a person discovering a new sport that they can become obsessed with, but Minami is an inviting protagonist and Haruka is a fine fit as the upperclassman enthusiastic about drawing a newcomer into the sport. In a writing sense, the episode does everything it needs to do to pitch its series, even including throwing in a vague bit of yuri baiting. The visuals, unfortunately, are a big limiting factor here. This is far from one of the best-looking shows of the season, and its detail-rich depiction of golf can only go so far to offset that. It’s the entire reason I’m not rating this one a notch or two higher, because otherwise I think this series has potential.

Tasokare Hotel

Streams: Amazon Prime on Fridays

Rating: 3.5 (of 5)

The Tasokare Hotel exists in a realm on the border between life and death, where guests check in free of charge to learn about themselves and which way they should go from here: on to the afterlife or back into the land of the living. They do so by being assigned to a room and investigating details found in the room (which can change from day to day) until they remember crucial details, often with the assistance of a hotel staff member. Until they remember their identities, their face (or in some cases entire head!) is not revealed. A girl who eventually remembers her name to be Neko Tsukahara is a newly-arrived guest with a mystery about how she ended up there (viewers see in an opening scene that she was apparently stabbed), but she finds helping another patron to sort out her identity and life to be interesting enough that she asks to stay on as staff, just like a porter named Hatori did before her.

This is a very odd little series which feels very much like one of those mystery-solving mobile games (which it is, in fact, derived from), so its main appeal is going to be to the kind of anime crowd who enjoys titles like Death Parade. Though there are indications of possible darker elements (both Neko and the other patron she helps ended up here because of some degree of bloody violence, for instance), the general tone is a bit more light-hearted and a number of odd supporting characters abound, including the manager whose head is a ball of flame, the apparently-human standoffish kitchen girl, the female bartender who’s dressed like a flapper and has horns, or the demonic-looking bar patron. There’s a sense that episodic mysteries may be framed by overarching mysteries involving Neko and Hatori, and that’s a perfectly fine structure to work with. I will probably give this one another episode or two to catch my interest, though normally this kind of series isn’t my thing.

I’m Getting Married to a Girl I Hate in My Class

Streams: Crunchyroll on Fridays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

Anime’s had a lot of situations over the years where youths have been caught in arranged engagements by parents or grandparents, but few grandparents have been as obnoxious about it as the set involved in this scenario. As crass as this set-up may sound, this is actually a high-energy comedy, and that energetic spirit is just enough to carry this starter episode. There’s also a very clingy female cousin of Saito’s and a gyaru who’s a close friend of Akane (and who is in love with someone, though whether it’s Saito or Akane is unclear at this point) to round out the core cast and doubtless offer additional complications. The first episode drops a lot of hints that should be fodder for future episodes, including suspiciously absent parents on both sides and a vague suggestion that Akane may be a full-blown tsundere here, so it doesn’t look like the series is going to depend just on romcom elements. I’m wary on this one, and the artistry is certainly nothing special, but I’m willing to give it a chance.

Thanks to meddlesome grandparents, archrival high school students Akane and Saito aren’t just getting forced into an arranged marriage; they’re actually legally married, assigned to live in the same “love nest” of a house, and even required to sleep in the same bed, all because their grandparents have regrets about how they didn’t hook up with each other at the same age (when they also had a strong rivalry) and so intend to make damn sure their grandkids don’t make the same “mistake.” Saito reluctantly puts up with this because it’s a precondition towards eventually taking over his grandfather’s highly-successful company (which will otherwise be relegated to being run by a stray dog), while Akane reluctantly does so for as-yet-unrevealed reasons whispered to her by her grandmother. But they still consider each other rivals and intend to maintain that appearance at school.

Momentary Lily

Streams: Crunchyroll on Thursdays

Rating: 2.5 (of 5)

Like all studio GoHands projects, this is an original animation effort, one helmed by the director of Coppelion, Hand Shakers, and most of the K franchise. And for all of the spectacle that’s going on visually, the plot may be the most ordinary of all of GoHands’ works: mysterious techno-aliens have appeared who erase any humans who get near them (leaving their clothes and carried items behind). All that’s now left in the otherwise-mostly-intact city are a quintet of teenage girls who all have crystals(?) called Andvari which can summon fantastical weapons which both protect them from the erasing effect and allow them to combat the techno-aliens. Then they meet a lone new girl wandering alone who lacks her memories from before the catastrophe but seems able to all a very potent weapon of her own.

Plot-wise, this seems like as standard a post-apocalyptic scenario as they come in anime, although the comment “we can’t become friends because it would be sad if we vanished” near the end of the episode is mildly intriguing and the random cooking segment in the middle seems so completely out of place that one character even apologizes for it. Nothing sticks out so far about any of the characters, either; they’re all walking anime stereotypes. But hey, it’s not any of that which matters here; it’s GoHands’ crazy visual style. This is the ultimate refinement of the techniques they have developed through previous titles, for better or worse, and mileage will definitely vary on that. The use of color is almost too vivid at times, with multiple lens and lighting effects in almost every shot (watch for rainbow effects around the edges of many shots), and GoHands’ trademark heavy use of ground-level angles and rotating viewpoints is in such full force that I could see tracking the action scenes leaving some viewers dizzy. That contributes to the action scenes being almost too busy to easily follow. Copious attention is also paid to animation of hair blowing around and the ample jiggling breasts of one (and later to a lesser extent two) of the girls, again for better or worse.

Honestly, the visual style presented here doesn’t bother me, so the lower grade is entirely based on the weak non-visual aspects. I’m just intrigued enough by what’s going on in the setting that I may watch more, but right now this isn’t looking like a keeper.

Grisaia: Phantom Trigger the Animation

Streams: Crunchyroll on Wednesdays

Rating: 2 (of 5)

This one is an odd acquisition for Crunchyroll, as it doesn’t have any of the other animation in this franchise. In fact, originating animation The Fruit of Grisaia and sequel The Eden of Grisaia are only available for streaming via Google Play (and only for purchase), and the prequel The Labyrinth of Grisaia is only available on BR and DVD, and the three installments of the OVA Grisaia: Phantom Trigger (for which this seems to be a sequel to) aren’t available legally in any form. The production staff may have been aware of the latter point, as they spend the first two minutes having one of the characters give a brief recap of the previous Phantom Trigger events, though I still think you have be to be at least generally familiar with the concepts underlying the franchise’s earlier installments (i.e., that Mihama Academy was a school for children who are assassins but is now a school to train elite operatives for covert organization SORD) for this to make any sense.

In this installment, Shiori Arisaka is a new teacher at Mihama Academy who is back in the classroom after some dangerous shenanigans. Taiga is an elementary student who is placed in Arisaka’s Class A because of her pedigree, where is she put under the guidance of explosives expert Chris. She’s gradually exposed to what all it means to be an agent with an eye towards making sure she respects the job and doesn’t get full of herself.

Going into this with only a passing familiarity with the franchise, I had a rough ride following the first episode. Because of this, I can only recommend this one to franchise veterans. Its artistic merits are ordinary and nothing about the first episode is compelling enough to make me want to figure things out. Big pass here.

Ameku M.D.: Doctor Detective

Streams: Crunchyroll on Wednesdays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

In this double-episode debut, Dr. Takao Ameku is a genius doctor in the Department of Investigative Pathology at the hospital her family runs, though she often gets mistaken for a high school student. She specializes in cases where diagnosis is difficult, but she also has a penchant for sticking her nose into any case she finds interesting. Such is the case with a soon-declared-deceased young man who arrives in the emergency room with blue blood and lower left leg apparently bitten off. With underling Dr. Takanashi and later two detectives in tow, she gets to the bottom of the sneaky cover-up.

In other words, this title based on a novel series is probably going to be one of those “mystery of the week” titles, albeit with a medical focus and the possibility that each “week” will cover two or more episodes. The first two episodes establish the key players and present a suitably twisty case whose solution at least partly depends on expert-level medical knowledge, and Dr. Takao is every bit the eccentric troublemaker that would be expected. (I couldn’t help but think of Maomao from The Apothecary Diaries, though her eccentricities are distinctly different.) It does look decent, and I could see it working for genre fans, but this type of series is really not my thing without bigger attached gimmicks than what we see here.

Headhunted to Another World: From Salaryman to Big Four!

Streams: Crunchyroll on Wednesdays

Rating: 3.5 (of 5)

In this manga adaptation, Dennosuke is an Overseas Manager for his company but feels very put-upon. Following an accident in his newest assignment, he finds himself summoned to another world by that world’s Demon Lord, who has specifically sought him out to be the fourth of his army’s lead generals, much to the dismay of both him and the other three generals (who, according to the OP, all happen to be hot ladies, though that’s not immediately obvious in the regular episode in two cases). Dennosuke doesn’t have any magic or special powers – he is, in fact, still a perfectly ordinary human – but he does have the negotiating and managerial skills that the immature demon nation desperately, and that’s exactly why the Demon Lord is so keen to secure Dennosuke’s services and convince him that he will be valued here. A test negotiation with a minotaur soon proves the Demon Lord right to at least one of his generals.

I was not expecting anything from this one at all, but was mildly surprised by how effective its approach is. There have been a few anime and LNs about situations where a hero’s party falls apart because the seemingly-worthless person who was actually keeping everything together was banished, but this is the reverse situation: the Demon Lord is fully aware that a stabilizing element is needed in his immature organization more than another powerhouse, and so is doing everything he can to recruit Dennosuke rather than just force him into the role. In other words, he’s trying to win Dennosuke over by being the ideal boss. This is a decidedly different tack than previous isekai efforts, and I’m quite interested to see where it goes. Artistic merits here are also sharper than the other isekai debuts so far this season – including a sexy female general exclusively featured in the ED – and a soundtrack which draws on American Southwest-flavored acoustic guitar provides additional interesting flavor. This one could be a keeper.

Possibly the Greatest Alchemist of All Time

Streams: Crunchyroll on Wednesdays

Rating: 2.5 (of 5)

In this light novel adaptation, Takumi was accidentally summoned to another world as part of a hero-summoning ritual. But this time it’s not the fault of the goddess; she’s just trying to correct a bad situation brought about by a worldly nation conducting a forbidden ritual. She doesn’t trust that Takumi would be treated well by that nation as an “extra,” so she diverted him and gave him her blessing to compensate. Takumi doesn’t want to be a hero or adventurer, so he tries to focus on developing craft skills, especially alchemy, as he establishes himself in the village of a girl he rescues from a monster. He also picks up a pet poisonous spider along the way. Meanwhile, at least one of the actual summoned heroes already has reason to be wary of the empress who summoned the trio, thanks to the secret blessing of the same goddess.

Let’s be frank here: this one is not worth watching because of the main character. He’s as bland as they come, and the first episode seems to be speeding him towards becoming OP as quickly as possible. Technical and artistic merits are also quite ordinary. What might make this one watchable is the bigger forces in play. There are heavy implications that the Sidonia Empire which summoned the heroes may be up to no good, and Goddess Nolyn’s moves seem more calculated than she’s letting on, even if she does seem to be genuinely concerned for Takumi. If the story keeps those elements in play then it could offset the show’s weaker aspects. Will watch a couple of episodes more before deciding if this one is a keeper or not.

Bogus Skill <<Fruitmaster>>

Streams: Crunchyroll on Mondays

Rating: 2 (of 5)

In Light’s world, people gain a skill from eating a special fruit, and that skill determines what kind of career they are best-suited to. But this can only be done once, as eating a second skill fruit is invariably fatal. Light was hoping for a combat-oriented skill so he can become an adventurer, but that instead went to childhood friend Lena, who was whisked off (despite her protestations) to become one of her generation’s heroes. Light instead gained Fruitmaster, which is as far from what he wanted as could be. But after months farming fruit, he accidentally discovers a hidden benefit of his skill: it makes him immune to poisonous fruit, so he’s the one person who can safely pick up a second skill. And that godly second skill may allow him to eventually stand with his childhood friend again.

This manga adaptation (which chains back to a light novel) looks destined to be one of the season’s bottomfeeders. The whole business with the fruits looks like just the newest gimmick to give everyone in the fantasy setting a guiding skill, and of course the protagonist gets the skill which looks weak at first but is actually totally game-breaking. And rather than have him gradually build up strength by acquiring multiple lesser skills and combining their abilities (which would have definitely been more interesting), he gets what’s apparently one of the strongest right away, hence giving him a shortcut to OP land. And of course he’s eventually going to be surrounded by a bevy of beauties, although one is a girl who looks like she may be 10 whom he lives with because she’s presumed to be an orphan. But hey, she picks up the Appraisal skill, which means she can mightily contribute to Light’s efforts even at such a young age.

Such an uninspired story construction is matched by equally uninspired visuals and a weak animation effort. I’ll probably watch another episode or two to see if this one will go anywhere interesting, but right now it’s not looking promising.

Beheneko: The Elf-Girl’s Cat is Secretly an S-Ranked Monster!

Streams: HIDIVE on Saturdays

Rating: 3 (of 5)

In this light novel adaptation, an unnamed knight dies in battle against demons and finds himself reincarnated in a dungeon as a baby behemoth, an S-ranked monster who, when fully grown, can terrorize entire nations. But at this age he looks just like an adorable kitten. Though capable of handling most monsters (and gaining skills from eating them), he finds himself on death’s door after an encounter with one of the few monsters he can’t currently handle, only to find himself rescued by Aria, an elf adventurer – a very busty elf adventurer, and one who doesn’t have the faintest clue what he really is. He decides to claim her as his master and become her knight, and she names him Tama, and thus a beautiful friendship begins. Of course, an all-too-aggressive fellow adventurer who wants Aria for his wife has to be dealt with first. . .

This one is clearly going to be one the season’s most fan servicey titles, as it does feature brief (uncensored) nudity and plenty of scenes of Tama riding around on Aria’s cleavage. Despite that, the first episode is actually more tame than it could have been, offering hope that it could be tolerable to those not so keen on fan service. It does use game mechanics quite prominently and doesn’t look the sharpest on the animation front (and the less said about the local Guildmaster, the better!), and those expecting it to be anything dramatically different than standard RPG-guided fare will be disappointed. However, Tama is adorable, and based on the first two volumes of the manga adaptation, the relationship which develops between him and Aria is a strong selling point. This won’t be a breakout series or anything, but it should provide reliable, sexy fantasy entertainment for the season.

Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon? V episode 11

Rating: B

The saying “it’s always darkest before the dawn” is practically a writing guideline for shonen action shows, and it is one that has often applied to this franchise, too. The situation isn’t at its absolute lowest point yet as the episode ends, as Hestia and her allied gods are all still safely in hiding (and remember, this is Hide-and-Seek, so their flowers getting taken is the true defeat here), but it’s definitely trending in that direction.

In this episode, we can see the alliance’s valiant efforts to compensate for the Freya Familia’s advantage. Haruhime’s Level Boost makes them at least more competitive against Freya Familia’s qualitative edge, Finn’s training of Lily at least partially offsets Hedin’s tactical brilliance, and the many magical swords provided by Welf (and to a lesser extent Hephaistos) can offset Hedin’s elite magic. Asfi’s items are also getting put to good use, and the combat-shy Nahza using her archery to dispute magic swords as needed is a neat trick.

However, there’s only so far that the alliance can go to even the playing field, and this episode also shows that. Hedin, who has much more experience both in general than Lily and with Freya’s followers specifically, can anticipate nearly everything the alliance will do except for Haruhime, so he keeps Freya’s forces concentrated to take advantage of their power gap. Freya Familia also has a trump card that the alliance can’t easily account for, and one that’s only been vaguely hinted at in the anime: it has the best healers of any combat-oriented familia. This makes sense, since the brutal training regimens of Folkvangr wouldn’t be possible to maintain without quality mass healing, but the real kicker is that that lead healer Heith is quite capable of defending herself against predictable headhunting strategies; she has both an amazing self-regeneration spell and combat capabilities easily good enough to fend off Level 2 adventurers. (She is a level 4 in official stat sheets.) The other big problem is that Bell’s Argonaut and Argo Vesta attack can actually match Ottarl when it’s at full charge, but it takes several minutes to reach that level (one minute per level, to be precise), so he can’t use it continuously. Even at Level 5, he’s still not even close to a match for Ottarl without that.

On the good side, we do finally get to see what some of these characters can actually do. Hegni, for instance, has not been shown in a serious fight previously, and the notion that his ace power involves a personality shift is rather amusing. This is also the first time we’ve seen Ottarl use an ability, as in every previous appearance his raw strength alone was enough. On the downside, some of what goes on here stretches credibility to the max. Yes, Freya Familia’s grunts are used to getting wiped out and getting back up from healing, but that still should take at least some toll, right? When this scene came up in the original novels, I was also bothered by how Heith seemed impervious to pain or disability while regenerating from horrific injuries, and the anime version doesn’t mitigate that one bit. I suppose we can assume that some kind of pain-numbing effect is part of Heith’s magic, but seeing her completely unbothered by the damage she took elicited an eye rool. At least the anime didn’t short-change the devastating effect the damage had on her clothing, even if it did keep her just barely decent. Sure, that can be looked at a fan service moment, but her clothing coming through any more intact than than would have strained credibility even more.

In general, the episode does a fine job of keeping the various confrontations and battlefronts in play, but ultimately, it’s just a collection of preliminary battles. The peak of the crisis is yet to come, and several important players have yet to enter the battle field. That includes the waitresses (Chloe and Lunoire), who announced their intention last episode; Mia, who is shown in the OP fighting Ottarl; and the return of Ryu. The Next Episode title strongly suggests that Ryu, at least, will be joining the action next time.

At this point, HIDIVE only has one more episode listed as upcoming. I can’t see how what’s left can be resolved in a single episode, and I’d heard said that this season was going to be 14 episodes, so I am curious to see how this is going to play out.

Review: Oshi no Ko (live-action)

Note: This review assumes the reader is familiar with the anime version and/or its equivalent content in the source manga. There will be spoilers for those who haven’t seen through the final episode of the anime’s season 2!

The live-action version of Aka Akasaka and Mengo Yokoyari’s Oshi no Ko manga is an ambitious project consisting of eight ONA episodes varying in length from 40 to 57 minutes, with the first six becoming available worldwide on Amazon Prime in late November and the last two becoming available earlier in December 2024. This review covers all eight episodes.

The series’ first episode covers mostly the same ground as the movie-length first episode of the anime version, though it mostly eliminates the scenes prior to the reincarnations; this won’t faze those familiar with the anime version, and some of those scenes are scattered throughout later parts of the series in flashbacks, but this approach makes the whole story less accessible to those for whom this version is their first exposure, as certain scenes in later episodes (especially ones where the ghost of Goro appears) might make less sense. Episode 2 covers the Sweet Today content (and so is equivalent to anime episodes 2-4), while episode 3 deals with the dating show (anime eps 5-7). Beyond that, direct comparisons get more muddled for a while, as the formation of the new B Komachi partly overlaps with the beginning of Tokyo Blade, which is a TV show instead of a stage play in this version. Hence episodes 4 and 5 are a condensed and remixed version of anime episodes 8-15, with Kana’s seeming scheduling conflict being explained by her taking over her Tokyo Blade role as an emergency fill-in rather than having been originally cast for it. Episode 6 finishes out the heavily-tweaked Tokyo Blade arc (and so is very roughly equivalent to anime episodes 16-20), while episode 7 covers Aqua’s meeting with Himekawa and the Miyazaki content (episodes 21-24), albeit without the supernatural aspects. Episode 8 is partly based on a few scenes that were left out of earlier content and partly forges on beyond the anime, with the series ending on a succession of major game-changing elements that point the story in the direction of the chapter-end flash-forward pages in the manga’s first volume.

While this story shouldn’t fundamentally be too difficult to do in live-action, some of the neatest visual gimmicks in the manga and anime versions had to be left behind. In particular, the starry-eye effect is used sparingly and more subtly, so much so that a franchise newcomer might miss it. Changes in expression and demeanor are instead used to emphasize when Aqua’s (and later Ruby’s) star goes black, and this has to be reinforced by the reactions of other characters. This version also has Aqua and Ruby be age 5 instead of 3 at the time of Ai’s death, hence allowing for actual child actors to speak their lines more convincingly, and greatly reduces the amount of time that “talking babies” is on the screen. The roles of assorted side characters are also minimized or cut out entirely, especially in the Tokyo Blade arc; that Melt is also in Tokyo Blade isn’t mentioned at all, for instance. In this version, Tokyo Blade is also more a drama than an action tale, so don’t expect any nifty fight scenes. Much (but not all!) of the series’ trademark showbiz commentary also gets trimmed.

The best aspect of this version is that it does maintain the story’s flow and signature scenes. As a trade-off for having to ditch the fancier visual effects of the anime version, costuming gets extra-special attention here; how certain characters were dressed at different times was always a significant background detail in the anime version, but the anime can’t hold a candle to the veritable teen fashion show of this version in that regard. Set dressings, especially in household shots, are also generally more elaborate and rich with credible details. Theme songs rotate with each episode, giving the series greater diversity in musical themes (though the anime version outshines it in use of background music). Some parts even play out every bit as well as in the animated version.

The key word in that last statement, though, is “some.” The effectiveness of individual scenes varies greatly, and the caliber of the acting has a lot to do with this. In general, actors for adult characters are smoother and more convincing; I especially liked the performances of producers Kaburagi and Raida. Among the main youth cast, the most consistently capable performance is probably Nanoka Hara as Kana. (Anime fans may know her as the Japanese voice of the titular character in Suzume.) She plays well off of both peers and adults alike. Nagisa Saito, who is a former idol group member, also acquits herself well as Ruby, as does Asuka Saito (a former Nogizaka46 member) as Ai. Unfortunately, the weakest performance is also the most important one: Kaito Sakurai, who does have other prominent live-action credits, just isn’t able to do much with Aqua. Granted, Aqua’s demeanor would have been hard for anyone to pull off well, but too often Aqua’s behavior feels forced, like Sakurai is just acting rather than being the character. (Which is ironic, given his character’s internal thoughts at times.) Camera angle choices in some scenes also leave a lot to be desired, as does a jittery camera effect which was sometimes probably intentional but sometimes didn’t seem to be.

Overall, this version provides an interesting alternate take in how to portray both the overall story and various key scenes, but that is the main extent of its value. It is hardly required viewing, as 90% of the time the anime version is clearly superior. A follow-up movie, subtitled The Final Act, is due to be released in theaters in Japan on December 20 and will presumably make its way to Amazon Prime sometime after that, which will go fully beyond where the anime version is so far and (presumably) finish out the story. It’s worth a look to franchise completists, but not something I can recommend beyond that.

Rating: B-

Review: The Lord of the Rings: The War of the Rohirrim

Though written, produced, and given a musical score by non-Japanese individuals (including Fran Walsh and Peter Jackson from the live-action The Lord of the Rings movies as Executive Producers), this wide theatrical release is officially an anime because it was animated by Japanese studio Sola Entertainment (Rick and Morty: The Anime, Tower of God), supported by a number of other Japanese studios, and directed by Kenji Kamiyama (Ghost in the Chell: Stand Alone Complex, Moribito – Guardian of the Spirit, Napping Princess). That being said, it’s clearly a film targeted at Western audiences, especially those who are long-standing fans of J.R.R. Tolkein’s works. It does have enough appeal that it could stand on its own as a rousing action-adventure story, however.

Of course, those not at all familiar with The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit will miss several important call-outs, such as a late reference to Gandalf, a brief late appearance by Saruman, references to and/or appearances of locations which are important in LotR’s main story, and even a brief, unexplained-in-the-movie appearance by Mordor lackeys looking for a ring. Newcomers will also miss the importance of the narrator’s identity (which is only revealed in the credits, but which should be recognized by anyone who’s seen the LotR movies in either live-action or animated form). However, the base story is not at all dependent on its setting: a princess who hasn’t outgrown her tomboyish ways despite reaching adulthood gets caught in the midst of a power struggle between her overbearing father and an ambitious noble, whose son, a former childhood friend of the princess, swears vengeance on her family after his father is accidentally killed in a duel. Driven by revenge, the former friend seeks to conquer the princess’s land (Rohan) by becoming the lord of outside forces, and partly through an act of treachery, drives the princess, her father, and the people they protect into a corner. The problems for the former friend are that the corner is a stalwart mountain fortress that would come to be known as Helm’s Deep and that he’s trying to conduct a siege in the dead of winter.

So yes, for LotR fans, this is a story set two centuries before the main story of LotR, about Helm Hammerhand and how that fortress which played such a crucial role in the LotR live-action movies came to be known as Helm’s Deep. More precisely, it’s the story of Hera, the youngest child of Helm, a character “unknown to history” who nonetheless played a pivotal role in Rohan existing as a nation in the form that it does in the modern times of LotR. (In fact, the current royal family of Rohan is a direct result of her actions, though not in the way you might initially expect.) Hera is both the story’s primary protagonist and its visual star, as her red hair dramatically stands out in contrast to everyone around her, and saying that she saves Rohan through her direct actions and leadership is not the slightest bit of an exaggeration. She also stands also the story’s strongest and most interesting character, as she’s a young woman who spurns any thought of marriage, is clever, can fight well on her own, is quick to adapt to changing circumstances, and accomplishes all of these without losing her emotional core. By contrast, her cousin Wulf is much more ordinary as a main antagonist who has strong leadership traits but gets so caught up in revenge and love for Hera turning into hate that he can’t listen to the good advice of a loyal subordinate. Helm Hammerhand is a little more interesting as the personally-indomitable king who’s too pridefully stubborn to trust the daughter he seeks to protect until it’s almost too late.

Essentially, the story beats form a fairly standard and generally predictable fantasy/historical epic power struggle. The general course of the story also bears striking similarities to how the LotR movie The Two Towers plays out; in particular, there are many (probably intentional) parallels to the events surrounding Helm’s Deep in that movie. Hence the main selling factors are Hera, the action scenes, and the visuals. Set designs, character designs, and use of color are all gorgeous, with Hera being predictably beautiful but also solid-looking enough to be convincing as an action figure. (She’s also clothed in practical fashion for the most part, and the somewhat awkward way she looks when in a dress in one early scene is a neat fine detail. The only exception to this is the wedding dress she wears for symbolic purposes for her big showdown at the movie’s climax.)

The animation effort, which depends partly on motion capture, is also a strong one, though not one without flaws. The integration of animated characters and backgrounds is the main issue, but thankfully it’s only a spotty one, and the movie dazzles in several of its elaborate action sequences. These aren’t all fights, either; one of the movie’s best-looking sequences is one where Hera must use climbing picks and crampons to scale a rock overhang to reach a giant eagle’s nest. But there are plenty of sharp-looking action sequences, too, ones which use shifting cameras to create greater dynamic movement and don’t rely at all on typical anime shortcuts; seeing characters do fully-animated dive-rolls in the middle of a fight is a joy. The sense of movement in fights is in some ways reminiscent of director Kamiyama’s earlier work Moribito, which only reinforces why he was the correct choice for this project.

The musical score for the movie outright borrows some of the musical themes from The Two Towers, and many others carry a similar flavor. That shouldn’t be a surprise; music composer Stephen Gallagher did work on Peter Jackson’s The Hobbit movies in a lesser role. Featured songs all fit that same feel, especially ending song “The Rider,” which I could see being a potential Academy Award nominee.

Though the movie does have a Japanese dub available, it is circulating in the U.S. with its English dub. The most interesting stories here are the casting of Brian Cox (who was once lauded for his performance in the titular role of King Lear) as Helm, a return to the franchise by Miranda Otto to narrate as Eowyn (a character from LotR who’s the spiritual descendant of Hera), and Saruman being voiced by the long-dead Christopher Lee using archival recordings. (Lee’s widow approved this and said her late husband probably would have been flattered by it.) The latter does, admittedly, sound slightly incongruous with the rest of the vocal performances, but it’s still a neat stunt. None of the other cast members are likely to be familiar to anime fans, but all filled their roles anywhere from adequately to very well.

Ultimately, the movie is a few minutes too long for its own good, and its unimpressive narrative somewhat hampers its visual appeal. Its strong musical score, good action scene and character designs, and appealing lead all help compensate, however, making this a middle-of-the-pack entry by franchise standards. It’s hardly a must-watch for franchise fans but one that I can recommend both as a standalone and as a franchise offering.

Overall Rating: B

Is It Wrong to Try to Pick up Girls in a Dungeon? V episode 10

Rating: B+

As announced at the end of last episode, the trouble with Freya is going to be resolved the classic Orario way: with a War Game. Yes, we’ve seen this before in the DanMachi universe – when a god became obsessed enough with Bell to go after him aggressively – and I can’t fault viewers for seeing this as just a replay of the matter with Apollo. However, there are four important differences this time:

  1. Last time it was just familia vs. familia. This time it’ll be Freya Familia against everyone else who wants to (and is allowed to) get involved.
  2. Last time this was a private matter, just between Hestia and Apollo. This time, though, all of Orario is impacted, and way more people than just Hestia Familia’s closest allies have cause to want to fight Freya Familia over this. Some are existing allies, some are those who have taken a liking to Bell and/or feel they owe him, some are pissed that Freya was audacious enough to charm everyone, and some are just taking an opportunist approach; the rewards will be rich if they succeed and there’s glory to be had.
  3. Apollo was a one-note, cartoonish villain motivated purely by lust. Freya is a much more complex character with more complicated and better-established motivations. (And that’s without factoring the still-comatose Horn into it.)
  4. This time around bigger issues are in play. Loki Familia is itching for a fight, as they’ve had plenty of trouble with Freya Familia even within the bounds of the main series and many (including their patron) are irate over being charmed. But the Guild can’t risk having them get involved, as having both of the most powerful familias in Orario getting weakened at the same time would both hinder the quest to eventually defeat the Black Dragon and invite disaster; the last time this happened (i.e., after Zeus and Hera Familias were practically wiped out fighting the Black Dragon), Evilus arose and wreaked havoc for years.

The latter point is a disappointment, as all of the DanMachi fandom is likely aching to see a knock-down, drag-out fight between the elites of Loki and Freya Familias, especially after the events of this season; the only two previous battles (Ais vs. Ottarl in s1 ep 8 and Ais vs. Allen and the prum brothers in Sword Oratoria ep 6?) were brief skirmishes. Narratively speaking, though, allowing that would be a very bad idea, as that would a) put the fight on a more even field and b) make the conflict more about Loki vs. Freya, which would distract both from the everyone vs. Freya spirit and from Bell being at the center of things. Within the story, that’s avoided because Royman, the Guild leader, is less concerned about justice than he is about Orario fulfilling its role – i.e., to cap the Dungeon and foster the heroes necessary to defeat the Three Great Quests. That’s why he even goes as far as bribing Finn with information that Loki Familia’s leadership can’t overlook as additional insurance that they’ll behave. (And on that note, the anime falls woefully short of clarifying why that broken sword in the crystal is such a big deal: it’s a major clue to a mystery Loki Familia has been ardently pursuing for many years, but Royman was unwilling to reveal it before now because getting to its source would be costly even for Loki Familia.)

But even with the coalition behind them, Hestia Familia is still at a major disadvantage, and as Ganesha himself points out, the “Hide-and-Seek” concept isn’t enough of a handicap given the might Freya Familia has at its disposal. Quality trumps quantity in the DanMachi setting, and the Hestia coalition doesn’t have anyone on the level of Freya Familia’s elites. In essence, it’s practically the reverse problem Hestia Familia faced in the War Game against Apollo Familia. They do have some things in their favor; Crozzo magic swords and Haruhime’s abilities are not trivial factors, Finn formally training Lily is partially offset the tactical wizardry of Hedin, and Asfi’s items have certainly proven to be wild cards in the past. And there are going to be a sizable number of mid-range adventurers amongst the mob. The OP strongly suggests that Mia will eventually step in, too, and her one scene this episode could be taken as a set-up for that; Mia doesn’t tolerate foolishness, and her goddess has certainly been foolish. Anyone who’s enough of a powerhouse that even Allen is concerned about her could certainly be a difference-maker. Cassandra’s vision and Ryu’s promise before jumping off the wall both suggest that she’ll be back to be a difference-maker at a crucial point, too. Tsubaki also proved in Sword Oratoria that she can hold her own even among Loki Familia’s elite. Still, they’re going after a group with Orario’s strongest warrior, one of Orario’s best tacticians and mages, and a large membership composed of individuals well-tested in head-to-head battles with other adventurers and backed by top-rate healers. And they’re all united in purpose (in most cases to a fanatical degree) behind their goddess.

There are a couple of interesting side stories set up by this episode beyond just the bribe Royman gives to Finn, though. Where, exactly, is Ryu going at a time like this? Given the state of things and what was revealed during s4, only one destination makes any sense: wherever Astraea currently is. She’s got a lot to talk about with her patron and is years overdue for a status update, so methinks we’ll see a stronger Ryu join the fight at a later stage. The implication that Allen went to see Ahnya is also intriguing, as it’s hard to figure what Allen’s purpose would be for doing so. We haven’t seen the last of that, either. Then there’s also the matter of Horn. Is she deliberately remaining comatose to preserve Syr?

One other point also probably requires some explanation for anime-only watchers: why Aiz isn’t involved in training Bell this time, and why Freya had any pull to make that happen. That’s a result of events in Sword Oratoria a few novels beyond where the anime adaptation stopped. Without getting much into spoilers, Aiz independently sought training from Ottarl to help her prepare to deal with one of that spinoff’s main antagonists, and Freya allowed it in exchange for a later favor. This is Freya calling in that favor.

On other fronts, the animation effort this episode seemed much more limited compared to previous episodes this season, but given the major battles which are coming, that’s not a big surprise. And seeing Lily being such a commanding figure towards the end was a nice touch.

The way the anime is presenting the setting for the War Game is not what I pictured while reading the novel, so I’m especially curious to see how the backgrounds play out as we get into the thick of things next episode. Ultimately, this is the standard pre-main battle set-up episode, but it still has plenty enough angles going on to stay involving.

Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon? V episode 9

Rating: A-

Given Hestia’s persistently undignified behavior, it can be easy to forget that she is actually a goddess. Even with her divine powers curtailed, she is still the supreme power in Orario within her domain: that of purity. Unfortunately for Freya, that domain is the one that stands most directly opposed to the allure of Freya’s charm. With the right stage set, Hestia (known as Vesta to the Romans, hence the episode’s title) can counteract even Freya’s city-wide charm, all in the most glorious scene she’s had in the whole franchise to date. And all it required was recreating a semblance of her heavenly altar across the length and breadth of the city without triggering the charm’s protective elements.

So does this mean that we can now start referring to Ouranos as a sneak old codger now? Because that was certainly a devious stunt he pulled with the firewood, one that Hestia apparently somehow caught onto. (The main failing of this episode is not elaborating more on this point, which the novel does do.) We’ve known since the beginning of the franchise that gods can use their ichor (i.e., blood) to inscribe Falna onto their followers and update their statuses, so it stands to reason that ichor could be used in other ways to apply a god’s blessing. In this case, Hestia had her ichor dripped onto firewood distributed across the city. When lit, it would effectively create a giant magical seal keyed to Hestia across the city, which would allow Hestia to manifest her heavenly temple in the Lower World. The sacred flame isn’t part of Hestia’s personal symbol (as seen on Bell’s back) or her familia’s symbol without reason, and it cleanses all impurities. This does beg the question of whether Hestia would lose this power if she ever did the deed with Bell, but that’s a thought for another day. . . What matters here is that it incontrovertibly shatters Freya’s charm. And that’s going to bring big and quick consequences, not the least of which is affirming that Ouranos is not someone you ever want to get smug with.

While that’s the episode’s most visually dramatic sequence, what’s going on at Freya Familia’s home is at least as important. Horn has released the imprisoned Ryu in hopes that she’ll be enough of a distraction for her to confront Bell (though it certainly seems like Hedin may have covertly helped make this happen). Even over Bell, she’s in the most difficult situation of everyone. Because of her bond with Freya, she’s privy to Freya’s heart more than anyone else, and she can’t stand to see the goddess she idolizes fretting through romantic uncertainties like any ordinary woman. But she’s also trapped in that her loyalty to her goddess is at odds with what she feels is best for her goddess. The big problem for her is that sometimes people can’t always correctly understand what’s best for themselves, and in this setting that applies to gods, too. Horn is theoretically ideally positioned to play that role for Freya, but she’s too close, and like too many of Freya’s other followers, she’s too possessive or fanatical. Ottarl sometimes gives the impression that he understands that, but he’s not the kind of person who could ever talk to Freya like that. Hedin isn’t the kind of person that anyone could talk to about emotions, either, but his actions are increasingly suggesting that he does understand that what his goddess claims and what she really wants aren’t necessarily the same thing. In his own way, he may be trying to maneuver Bell not into being the person that Freya wants, but into the person that Freya needs. That bears watching going forward.

And let’s not forget that Bell’s confrontation with Freya is the boldest and most confident he’s ever looked, and that is a treat in itself. Like everyone else, Freya has underestimated him, but this time in terms of his emotional convictions. As much as she might want to, he’s not going to let her deny Syr or the genuine feelings she showed as Syr. He’s not going to let her hide behind the veneer of a goddess’s capriciousness anymore. Hestia mentions that Freya’s big mistake was abandoning Babel, but an even bigger one was letting Bell see her real feelings. Presumably, something about this is going to be at stake in the upcoming War Games; though Freya is proposing it, it’s also probably the only way to settle the rampant city-wide anger at Freya’s actions.

I also have to add praise again for the animation effort, which has been at the top of its game once again. Ryu’s battle scenes looked sweet, but the range of expressions Horn goes through as she rants at Bell was also impressively well-animated. Solid musical support, too, especially in the confrontation scenes.

With this episode, the adaptation of novel 17 ends. Next up, with adaptation of novel 18, is the arc’s climax: the War Game against Freya Familia.

Special Preview: Solo Leveling – ReAwakening

Rating (compilation part): 3 (of 5)

Rating (new episodes): 3.5 (of 5)

Solo Leveling is returning to TV for the Winter 2025 season, and this special theatrical presentation provides both a roughly 80 minute compilation of the first season and an advance look at the first two episodes of the second season. It was out in theaters in the States today (Wednesday 12/4/24), so this preview is based on a screening of the subtitled version at an IMAX theater.

The compilation is less a summary of the first season and more a highlight reel designed to help refresh the memories of established fans. If you’re new to the franchise, don’t rely on this to inform you enough to be able to follow the second season, as it skips over a lot of important details. The heaviest emphasis is on Jinwoo’s fight against the snake, the affair with Hwang Donsuk’s party, and the class change battles, the latter of which are replicated almost in full, but you’ll see very little from the set-up in the first two episodes. Since the strength of the first season lay in its detailed battle scenes, getting to rewatch them on an IMAX screen was a real treat. In fact, in general, limiting the content mostly to the major battle scenes emphasizes the strengths of the series while minimizing its weaknesses.

The first two new episodes (which I hope are released together as the debut, since they form a story mini-arc which doesn’t have a good break point in it) involve Jinwoo escorting the high school girl from the C-rank dungeon raids with Jinho (who turns out to be a classmate of his sister) as observers with a raid party of mostly B and A-ranked hunters. Things, of course, go awry when the gate goes red, thus trapping the team in a snowy landscape until the local boss can be defeated. The main threats here are giant bears and elf-like assailants, which combine to pose a severe threat to everyone else but mostly just give the even more dashingly-handsome Jinwoo an opportunity to show off what his new class can do. Various flashy battles ensue, as well as yet another Hunter turning ugly at his failures.

While these two episodes do bring up a couple of potentially interesting world-building points – this is the first time that dungeon adversaries who can talk have been encountered, and they seem to be subject to some guiding force – these two episodes mostly serve to finish a major shift for the story. No longer is this about Jinwoo having to get stronger just to survive; it’s now about him showing off as a total OP badass. Granted, there’s an S-ranked Hunter (and I’m guessing one of the stronger ones?) now gunning for him, but Jinwoo now seems to be at least on that level, and he’s got a whole damn shadow army at his disposal, too, complete with powerful new recruits from these episodes. Could be interesting to see if the series can keep ratcheting up the challenge level enough to maintain the kind of tension which characterized key fights in the first season, but at the very least, the high-powered musical score is back to give the action all of the dramatic backing it could ask for. On the downside, Jinwoo is progressively becoming less interesting as a character as his flaws and self-doubts continue to fade away.

Basically, if you were a big fan of the first season then you’ll probably find a lot more to like with this opening. If you weren’t then these new episodes offer little hope of changing your mind.

Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon? V episode 8

Rating: A-

In all heroic stories where things go bad, there is a turning point. In the case of this arc, that “point” is the entirety of episode 8. No action in this episode can single-handedly carry that distinction, but taken together numerous actions set the path forward for climbing out of the hole that Freya Familia has dug.

The first issue is that, for as all-encompassing as Freya’s charm seems to be, there are gaps beyond just Hestia and Eina’s incident a couple of episode back. Freya knows it, and so does her upper echelon, and so they’re starting to sweat Bell’s continued resistance, even if it is flagging in the face of training even some Freya members are starting to acknowledge is going overboard. The Xenos are too deep to be influenced, and so is a Loki Familia expedition to deep levels headed by Riveria. (What, exactly, this expedition is for has not, to my knowledge, been revealed in the novels, either – or at least the ones published so far in English anyway – as Sword Oratoria’s novel 12 happens between seasons 3 and 4.) How someone as powerful as Riveria might influence the situation is a legitimate worry, enough so that reassignments in anticipation of her group’s eventual return passes the smell test with the Freya rank and file. But that’s not the last suggestion this episode that Hedin is definitely up to something. He seems to be both pushing Bell and giving him opportunities.

The second factor is Mia. Although novel readers knew this for a while at this point, the anime version has only suggested that she is a retired Freya Familia member. This episode confirms both that and that Mia did, indeed, have some kind of agreement to stay out of what Freya was doing. But she’s also clearly shown as far back as the first season that she doesn’t tolerate crap, and the stunt Freya is pulling here is a big heaping load of it. Her tolerance only goes so far, and so she gives Bell the words he needs to hear, even if he’s too much in depression to realize it immediately.

The third factor, unsurprisingly, is Ais. We knew from previous episodes that she was affected, but maybe not completely; she is, after all, both part spirit and emotionally stunted, and had a connection to Bell maybe even as strong as Hestia’s (if in a different way). Even so, an Ais who has only vague impressions of her established connections to Bell is enough. Would this encounter have happened if Freya Familia members were still tailing Bell? Probably, because nothing short of Freya personally being present could have stopped the encounter, and even familia elites (other than maybe Ottarl) couldn’t have taken on a trio of level 6s without consequences. Still, them not being around meant that Bell could collect himself without anyone being the wiser – and my, Hedin seemed at least a little happy about that, didn’t he? That’s the nail in the coffin that he’s not as fully committed to this scheme as everyone else, though why is the lingering mystery when his devotion to Freya doesn’t seem to be any less than that of the others.

And then, of course, there’s Hermes, who, other than Ouranous and Hestia, is the most problematic of the gods. Even under the charm, Hermes is too clever to not notice that things are off (with Asfi not being present, and him not knowing where she is, being the biggest clue), and he’s clever enough to figure out a way to leave breadcrumbs that even the charm can’t negate when it inevitably interferes with his memory when he gets too close to the truth. How do you fight a charm like this without being aware that you’re fighting it? Put yourself in a situation where you’re being told what to do without knowing the reason why. Honestly, it’s a brilliant plan, especially given the limitations he’s operating under.

And it’s even more brilliant when you consider that the note he left Hestia, which he had to come up with on very short notice and hastily scribbled out, fits perfectly into that resistance. Current Hermes may not know why it’s important to turn all of Orario into one big hearth, but he knows himself, he knows Hestia, and he knows that’s her domain. If something is affecting his memories, and Hestia can resist it, then the key is to find a way to transfer that resistance to the city as a whole. The particulars may be murky at this point, but the firewood deliveries Hermes Familia have been tasked with almost certainly have everything do do with that scheme. Gotta give a few more creds to Ouranos at this point!

And lastly, in a way, Syr is a factor here, too. Getting into a relationship with Bell as Syr may have been something Freya deeply wished for, but it’s looking more and more like trying to corner Bell as Syr was the biggest mistake she could have made. as Bell’s memory of her is the final barrier when he’s on the brink of giving up. But that, combined with all the other factors, allows Bell to collect himself in true heroic fashion. It’s now looking a lot less promising that Freya Familia can keep things together, especially with one of their own seeming to very subtly sabotage them. And don’t forget that Ryu is locked away somewhere, too, even if we didn’t see her this episode.

Finally, kudos to the musical score for this episode. This franchise has a long-standing and well-earned representation for superlative use of its musical themes, but this episode enforces how effective it can be outside of major battle scenes, too. This also feels like the best the series has ever looked artistically. Given next episode’s title – “Vesta,” which is Hestia’s counterpart in Roman mythology – a major reversal may be looming, and I can’t wait to see it play out.

Fall ’24 Mid-Season Report, part 2

See here for part 1.

This half of the report covers Orb (which I somehow overlooked in my first half) and all fall season series I have been following which are first hitting episode 6 or 7 between 11/16 and 11/20 inclusive. Mostly these are the series that were later starters, though in one case (Reincarnated Aristocrat) the series is here instead of in part 1 because it took an unexplained week off.

Arifureta 3

Rating So Far: C+

Thanks in part to much improved technical merits, this anime adaptation has gradually become more watchable as has progressed into its third season. It also gets a somewhat interesting plot line going about how the Haulia Bunny Tribe decides to start asserting itself politically, too, with only a comparatively minor helping hand from Hajime. That being said, it’s still blatant edgelord fare, to the point of absurdity; Hajime and crew now fly around on a massive sci fi airship that would look more fitting in outer space, and I think it may actually be impossible at this point for Hajime to make a mistake. I’m really starting to wonder if how seriously this series takes itself isn’t part of a really big joke. It’s barely passable as lowbrow fare.

As A Reincarnated Aristocrat, I’ll Use My Appraisal Skill to Rise in the World 2

Rating So Far: B

While the first season did set the bigger plot in motion, it largely focused on assembling Ars’ core supporters and allies. This season has moved on to dramatically advancing the plot, sometimes with diplomacy and sometimes with Ars facing his first real, direct battles. Along the way his Appraisal ability essentially levels up, too. The series is doing a pretty good job so far of showing how Ars is gradually growing into the role of being a leader who could conceivably rise much further, but this would all be a bit more credible if Ars is allowed to age up some more. At least he’s not having it easy; no shortage of capable foes are popping up in his path.

Bleach: Thousand-Year Blood War p3

Rating So Far: B-

At this point, I’m watching Bleach much more because I’m a completionist than because I care about the storyline. Other than Uryu having turned on Ichigo and friends/allies and Grimmjow being back as a kinda-sorta ally, this story about Ywatch killing, absorbing, and replacing the Soul King isn’t mechanically much different from any of the franchise’s previous apocalyptic storylines. Like its predecessors, the plot has little more to it than an excuse to set up lots of flashy battles. That being said, the flashy battles are amazingly flashy. The franchise has never looked better than (for example) episode 33, and that and the way the series is getting just about everyone who’s ever appeared before and is still alive involved is enough to carry the content on its own. So turn your brain off and come for the sheer spectacle; who cares if it makes sense?

Demon Lord 2099

Rating So Far: B-

This “reincarnate into the future of the same world” tale invited initial comparisons to The Demon Sword Master of Excalibur Academy, and despite being an entirely different style of show, it still maintains some structural similarities. It is also easily the season’s most overlooked and underappreciated series. A former demon lord becoming a pompous, arrogant gaming streamer to reconstitute his worship-based power is a neat and fitting approach for a cyberpunk-influenced setting, and there are some unexpectedly philosophical elements involved when Veltol encounters the still-existing former hero, now reduced to being a vagabond. It can also surprise with some remarkably lavish action sequences, highlighted most by some in episode 6, and features a solid core cast. If you passed this one by at the beginning of the season, consider giving it another chance.

Nina the Starry Bride

Rating So Far: B

Nina may still act immaturely at times – she’s certainly no Shurei from The Story of Saiunkoku – but few anime heroines persevere more thoroughly on raw gumption than she does, and that (along with some protection by gorgeously handsome princes!) has enabled her to navigate some deadly-dangerous situations and still come out ahead;. Even a prince intent on using her (unknown to him, fake) status as a priestess-princess to start a conquest of her home country is having trouble reckoning with her, as even being slashed across the chest by a sword doesn’t stop her. Some big plot twists towards the end of episode 7 promise that the story will remain lively. On the technical side, the series benefits from some very pretty character designs, but the more subdued coloring prevents the look of the series from standing out.

Orb: On the Movement of the Spheres

Rating So Far: A

I may be a little biased here, since I’m a sucker for historical dramas. However, for as ugly as the content can be (torture, suicide, violent deaths, and characters being burned at the stake have all been a thing), this is a beautifully-rendered version of a manga that was known much more for its keen writing than visuals (especially in regard to its limited background art!), and it does so without sacrificing the writing one bit. These are sharply-defined characters who each have their own well-developed world views as they struggle to pursue the truth of the universe (i.e., heliocentrism) – even if that pursuit might put them at odds with the Church. Stunning twists, dramatic events, and an especially strong musical score are all highlights of one of the year’s most cerebral series. It’s my current front-runner for Best of Season honors and, unless it flounders in its second half, will likely to make my Top 10 (if not Top 5) for the year.

Ranma ½

Rating So Far: B+

The original Ranma ½ anime adaptation has long been one of the most beloved series in Western fandom, so many familiar with it approached this new version with trepidation. However, a strong case can be argued that this version is better. With support from a crisp animation effort, the series looks great, and the tighter and more efficient storytelling keeps events moving along. It proves that it can hit more sentimental notes when it needs to (see the first half of episode 5), but it also deftly captures the spirit of madcap fun which characterized the earlier version. Nowhere does that show more strongly than episode 7’s epic “Rhythmic Gymnastics Martial Arts” showdown. (For newcomers, this is just the first in a regular running gag of making martial arts versions of activities that have nothing to do with martial arts.) The wonderful English dub is hitting all the right notes, too. Sure, there’s a big controversy over some mild censoring involving butt cracks and nipple-less breasts, but that’s ultimately a trivial issue to me. If you were holding off checking this one out because “remake,” don’t; you’re missing the season’s funniest series.

Seirei Gensouki: Spirit Chronicles 2

Rating So Far: B

Frankly, I didn’t have a high opinion of the first season when it first aired (due in no small part to the MC being a blatant Kirito clone), but the series grew on me more during a rewatch immediately prior to its second season’s debut, and that has carried over into this season. The lackluster personality of Haruto/Rio is still the series’ weakest point, but he is unusually insightful for an OP lead and he does at least have the conflict over keeping his past and present lives separate as he interacts with the newcomers from Japan (including his former love and biological little sister!) and one of the other summoned Heroes. Essentially, the series depends primarily on the people around Haruto being much more interesting, and giving significant chunks of the content from viewpoints other than Haruto’s doesn’t hurt. The seeds of greater plot threads lain in the first season are also now starting to bear fruit, including some surprising reappearances by characters first seen early in the series. It still hasn’t strayed far from being an OP power fantasy at heart, but it has more going for it than the lesser isekai series this season.

Shagri-La Frontier 2

Rating So Far: B+

There may not be much plot to this series, and it may not amount to anything more compelling than watching the MC get into all sorts of antics in VR games, but it still tackles what it does with gusto. The animation alone doesn’t get the credit for that, although it is a big factor; the design of the action scenes deserves at least as much credit. Sunraku also doesn’t give enough credit for how much his smarmy personality helps carry the series, either, whether he’s playing in Shangri-La Frontier or some other rando VR game. The SF Mini bits also deserve a shout-out, especially the one at the end of episode 6 about customers at an armorer being creeped out by Sunraku jealously staring in from outside. Still among the season’s most purely entertaining series.

The Do-Over Damsel Conquers the Dragon Emperor

Rating So Far: B-

This one is probably my second-favorite new series of the season (behind only I’ll Be a Villainess), but I have to rate this one distinctly lower for a couple of reasons. The first is that the series doesn’t entirely divorce itself from the inherent creep factor of a grown man having a physically 10-year-old girl as his bride, even if she is mentally older (though he doesn’t know that) and nothing physical is going on. Revelations over the course of the season have shown that his preference for girls under 14 isn’t a lolicon fetish, but rather a security measure (a fragment of a jealous goddess oriented on him can possess women age 14 or older), but that still seems a little too convenient. The balancing of cutesy and serious elements could also be better, but that’s a minor factor compared to the animation limitations that occasionally include still frames in the midst of action scenes – disappointing, since at other times the action flow actually looks pretty good. On the plus side, Jill is a delight and calls up comparisons to Tanya from The Saga of Tanya the Evil as the prepubescent-looking girl in a military uniform with a military attitude, and the contrast between her gung-ho confidence and occasional cutesy moments is utterly adorable. Not hard at all to understand how she wins people over despite her age. The musical score is a big plus on this one, too. Even with the growing animation problems, this is still a very fun series.

The Healer Who Was Banished From His Party Is, in Fact, the Strongest

Rating: B-

I was going to rate this one a step lower, but a strong episode 7 – one which furthers two key relationships and reinforces in a big way that a bigger plot is in motion – bumps the evaluation up overall. It also doesn’t hurt that this is one of the better-looking of the lower-tier fantasy series this season, with some actually decent animation, and has a co-lead in Narusena (featured above) who more than makes up for the bland personality of the titular character. Add in a potential romance beyond just the main characters and we have an RPG-styled fantasy series which seems to be striving to be more than just a typical tale about dungeon-crawling. The limp personality of Laust (who is, of course, far more capable than rumors about him suggest) is still a limiting factor on what this series can accomplish, but this one is still at least a step above the season’s bottomfeeders.

Fall 2024 Mid-Season Report, part 1

Week 7 of the Fall ’24 season marks the season’s official midway point, so let’s take a look at how some of the series airing this season are doing.

Like with the past three seasons, I am keeping up with a massive number of series this season (23 to be exact), so I am once again splitting this endeavor into two parts to keep it from being too cumbersome a read. The titles in this part are the ones that I am following which have reached episode 7 by 11/15/24. Next week’s installment will cover tittles that are hitting episode 7 or (in a few cases) 6 in the period of 11/15-11/21. And no, DanMachi will not be covered in either of these pieces since it is getting separate episode reviews.

So without further ado. . .

2.5 Dimensional Seduction

Rating So Far: B-

This series is at its best when emphasizing the different motivations for cosplaying and the way that relationships can build through cosplaying, and both of those factors are strongly evident this season as Nonoa becomes a cast regular, Mikarin returns to more active participation, and final girl Aria (the blonde who’s the redhead in the shot above) enters the stage. The love triangle dynamic created by Mikarin’s return is less effective (partly because she’s the only one who seems to be aware that there is a love triangle), but Aria compensates for that as a young woman seeking to cosplay to show love for her divorced father’s manga and hope to get his attention by becoming famous in the cosplay scene. Her more extroverted personality also fills the last gap in the group’s personality dynamic. Though Okamura is mostly reduced to the role of a supporting character by this point, he still makes important contributions, too. The somewhat flat coloring and unremarkable artistic effort still hamper this one some, but if anything its appeal as a story may be growing as it progresses.

365 Days To The Wedding

Rating So Far: B

Fake romance stories share one thing in common with real romances: how much you want to see the couple together is the single most important factor to the series’ success. That’s by far the biggest plus this series offers, as Takuya and Rika absolutely belong together: they both have similar levels of attractiveness, they both have similar levels of social awkwardness (though in somewhat different ways), and they both fit a gap in each others’ lives. The seven episodes so far all put them in situations to test whether their relationship can become more than just a fake engagement, including a surprisingly sober episode about a coworker and his family being shaken up by his wife unexpectedly seeking a divorce. Credit also goes to the staff for making the most of what feels like a relatively limited animation budget, and it’s hard not to appreciate a story focused on potential romance between two adults in the anime landscape. It may be one of the season’s more low-key offerings, but it’s a delight nonetheless.

DAN DA DAN

Rating So Far: A-

And we go from the season’s most low-key title straight to its most brazen. While I would not number this one among my favorite titles of the season, there are legitimate reasons why it’s both a critical darling and the most popular title of the season, even over former megalith Re:Zero. For starters, it’s arguably the most ambitiously and dynamically animated series of the entire year. While I prefer the prettier visual aesthetic of the animation used in Frieren or The Apothecary Diaries, neither of them has anywhere near the energy or sense of motion that this one does, and boy, does the storytelling provide ample opportunities to show that off! The appeal of the series goes well beyond just that, though. Okarun and Momo make a fabulous central duo (in addition to Momo being a great character on her own), Momo’s hot grandmother is a lively and unique supporting character, and even the villain “Turbo Granny” is tolerable now that she’s relegated to being a plushie. Episode 7 also surprised with a heartbreakingly poignant backstory explaining how the second major antagonist came to be the ghost Acrobatic Silky and linked to secondary girl Aira. Let’s not forget that it has one of the year’s best OPs, either, and its ED also isn’t shabby.

Good-Bye, Dragon Life

Rating So Far: C+

For the most part this has been a very run-of-the-mill pure reincarnation tale, in this case involving a former dragon reborn as a human man but with many of his draconic powers still intact. The main difference-maker has been the presence of the young-adult lamia Celina, though an encounter that protagonist Dolan had with a literal goddess he knew in his dragon life was also interesting. The move to a battle-heavy scenario in the last couple of episodes has been less effective, partly because Dolan, for all his power, just isn’t that interesting to watch in a fight. The portrayal of elves in this setting has also been thoroughly underwhelming (especially compared to how much attention is given to how Celina moves), and the world-building in general is a weak point. Offsetting that somewhat is a capable female magic knight who doesn’t (at least yet!) seem romantically interested in Dolan. This one is definitely watchable, and doesn’t look bad artistically (though the animation quality is less robust), but it is only borderline for being decent in a qualitative sense.

I’ll Become a Villainess Who Goes Down in History

Rating So Far: B+

I almost rated this one a notch higher, but a 7th episode where the titular character was mostly absent as part of a curious way to handle a time jump holds the series back some, even if that episode did serve its purpose (i.e., to give a full outside perspective on what’s transpiring). Beyond that, this is easily my favorite new series of the season, with Alicia making for the ideal spunky villainess-wannabe, with the twist that most of her efforts to be a villain wouldn’t actually be considered true villainy by objective viewers, but rather a level of pragmatic “tough love” that captures positive attention she doesn’t intend to get. The angle of Alicia serving as a break on the runaway idealism of heroine Liz, and Alicia getting into danger because she’s not getting sucked into Liz’s almost cult-like following, is also interesting (even if not completely original).

Let This Grieving Soul Retire

Rating So Far: B-

I wavered on rating this one this high, but ultimately leaned towards the generous side because I find the fundamental concept to be that amusing: Krai leads the the land’s most powerful adventuring group, and his every decision is regarded with respect and awe and in the most favorable possible light, but he’s painfully aware that he’s by far the least of his compatriots when it comes to monstrous talent (he can only get by with seeming powerful because he uses a ton of magic items) and so is always seeking ways to minimize what he has to do, whether it be foisting management duties on subordinates or getting clan underlings to do investigations for him. His only real talent is being able to manage his exceedingly eccentric childhood friends, but after seeing how some of them act, that group needs a stable pragmatist at its core, and the other members seem to recognize that even if Krai doesn’t himself. Much like with Mia in Tearmoon Empire, seeing Krai get way more credit than he wants or deserves, even as he tries to dodge having to do anything, is endlessly entertaining.

Loner Life in Another World

Rating So Far: C

This group isekai series has a lot of factors stacked against it: some of the season’s weakest artistic and technical merits, over-reliance on the game aspects, little that’s interestingly different going on, and hardly anyone but the MC and an emergent antagonist among the students being allowed to be both creative and effective with their powers. Despite that, I can’t bring myself to hate the series and am still watching it. Haruka’s commitment to the loner role helps fends off potential harem elements, and that the Class Rep snagged one of the most potent abilities mostly to keep anyone else from abusing it is also a neat touch. It’s my lowest performer of the season so far, but not the series I’m following that I’m least enthusiastic about.

Magilumiere Magical Girls Inc.

Rating So Far: B

I love the concept here: magical girls are adult women doing a job for a specialized business (or, in some cases, specialized departments of more regular businesses), and the different ways this can be done are examined through the eyes of the newest employee at a magical girl start-up. The execution of the concept has been solid, too, as protagonist Kana has gotten to witness magical girls that are aggressive, elegant, or businesslike working for companies that focus on aesthetics, improvisation, or efficiency, as well as experiencing the very tech-like nature of this form of magic. The most recent episode has even raised hints of a bigger plot involving the “Kaii,” which serve as the threat necessitating magical girls, possibly evolving into something more dangerous. The series looks pretty good (if a bit flat) and has a likable diversity in its cast, including at least one who seems to have a loaded backstory. This may not be top-tier entertainment for this season, but it has proven to be a reliable performer so far.

Mecha-Ude

Rating So Far: C+

The strongest thing this series has going for it is its almost manic, Studio Trigger-styled action pieces featuring the titular aliens and the hosts they have “derized” with to feed off of their host’s “Arbitrium” (whatever that is). The problem is that the series depends too much on that element, leaving other aspects anywhere from partly to wholly unsatisfying. Some of the specific blame for this is pacing that is, at times, frenetic, especially in the most recent episode. I am also not a fan of the very angular art and character design styles, and a muddled plot and a bunch of characters I don’t care about don’t help. I’m giving this a halfway decent rating out of respect for the action sequences, but this is the title closest to the cut line of all the titles this season that I’ve watched to the halfway point or beyond.

Re:Zero s3

Rating So Far: B+

Most of the core cast members (sans Ram and Rem) have gathered in Watergate City, along with all of the Royal Selection candidates, and four Archbishops of the Witch’s Cult (previously-introduced Greed and Gluttony and newly-introduced Wrath and Lust) and their minions are there, too. Add in a new bard character and a whole lotta mayhem is going down – in other words, par for the course for the franchise. I am less than thrilled about Beatrice being sidelined partway into the season (though she still has importance as something the Witch’s Cult is seeking), but Emilia remaining active despite effectively becoming a prisoner helps offset that, and that is one hell of a speech that Subaru gives in episode 7 (57 overall). This isn’t the franchise’s strongest run of episodes, but the series still doesn’t disappoint.

Sword Art Online: Gun Gale Online s2

Rating: B

Prior to seeing episode 7, I was going to say that the twist which resulted in the formation of the BTRY team during Squad Jam 3 was the most disappointing of the season (if not the year), as it killed the full-blown LLENN/Pitohui team-up that was promised at the beginning of the season. The second big twist near the end of episode 7 has forced me to re-evaluate that thought, however, as the episode’s very last scene offers up the possibility of an even more interesting scenario, and earlier scenes offer up the suggestion that something of concern might be going on in the real world, too. All of the tops a season that has, so far, entirely consisted of one long in-game battle, but at least there’s been enough antics with all the different groups involved to maintain interest. This spin-off has never indicated that it isn’t meant to mostly be about lengthy online battle scenarios, but I still feel like there’s at least some room here for more plot beyond just the games (unlike Shangri-La Frontier, where the plot is in the game), and the lack of that is why I can’t rate this one higher.

That’s it for part 1! Nearly all of the titles feeding into part 2 air over the weekend or early in the week, so part 2 should be posted late on 11/20/24.